It would not be considered good style today; - we'd say, "Paras, Lud and Put were ..."
However, you will often hear more than one 'and' in conversation, especially to stress the number:
Lindsay and Emma and Fred were there.
It's perfectly acceptable when we see the expressions containing 'and' as units:
Sausage and mash and fish and chips are traditional English meals.
Thanks teacher fivejedjon!
Is similar sentence like the following acceptable too?
"Sausage and mash and fish and chips and toast and marmalade are traditional English meals."
In other words, no maximum no. of “and” is limited to put in a single sentence if there is need?
Last edited by dawnngcm; 02-Oct-2011 at 13:50. Reason: typo
I'd go for:
"Sausage and mash,andfish and chips and toast and marmalade are traditional English meals."
However, your version is possible.
ONLY A NON-TEACHER'S OPINION
(1) I think that it is not only "correct" but even preferable and quite elegant.
(2) When you say or write "Paras, Lud, and Put were in your army," it seems
to me that you are not emphasizing the equality of all three persons so much as
when you say "Paras and Lud and Put were in your army." What do you think?
(3) In other words, many times the use of a comma or of the conjunction "and"
seems to be a matter of style.
(4) I found this in The Elements of Grammar by Margaret Shertzer:
Reading and writing and arithmetic are still basic.
(a) I think that such a sentence is stronger than "Reading, writing, and arithmetic
are still basic." What do you think?
(5) Tom: How many houses do you have?
Mona (a very rich and snobbish woman): Well, dear, I have homes in New York and
London and Beijing and Moscow and Buenos Aires. I'm currently thinking of buy one
in Warsaw.
(a) It is only my opinion that using commas would have made the sentence
"weaker." What do you think?
(6) Of course, you do not want to do this too often. In other words, it could seem
strange or even child-like to use "and" too often:
My friends are Tom and Sue and Tony and Mona and George and Alicia and Jose
and Marta. (You would be out of breath!)
Thanks TheParser for your sharing.
I’ve been taught “and” is used to join two expressions. Commas with “and” are used to separate and join two or more expressions, “and” is put before the last.
So “and” is used for emphasizing the equality, stress the number and treat it as units like teacher fivejedion said, I haven’t heard before.
It is new concepts and interesting usages of “and” to me.
P.S.
I checked different versions, they are,
NIV – Men of Persia, Lydia and Put served as soldiers in your army. They hung their shields and helmets on your walls, bringing you splendor.
NJB – Men from Persia, Lud and Put served as warriors in your army; hanging up shield and helmet in you, they displayed your splendour.
GNE – Soldiers from Persia, Lydia, and Libya served in your army. They hung their shield and their helmets in your barracks. They are the men who won glory for you.
I’m not sure if it is right to write another question about English writing in the Bible here, for this already is a long thread.
If administrators think it is not so good, please let me know what I should do next time / feel free to redirect it wherever you think it is appropriate. Thanks!
Ezekiel 12:23
The time has come [GNE] / The days are coming [NJB] / The day is near [NRSV, NIV]
I checked Oxford advancer learner’s dictionary, it said ‘come – Time (old-fashioned, informal) when the time mentioned comes.
Is ‘come / near’ still used normally today to describe the time mentioned / plan scheduled is close?
P.S.
1. Day / time are abstract nouns, it seems a bit odd that they can actually come / near;
2. I checked other modern versions Bible like ‘New Living Translation (©2007)’ and ‘English Standard Version (©2001)’, it used ‘The time has come’ and ‘The days are near’ respectively. However, some version like King James 2000 Bible (©2003), it used ‘The days are at hand’.
Thank you in advance!
Context is always important; labelling is rarely important.
Thanks teacher 5jj!!!
And thanks teacher Tdol for still letting me ask question in this thread!![]()