[Grammar] I have enclosed it IN/TO?

[felliot]

Hello!!! :)

I have enclosed it IN my application or
I have enclosed it TO my application?

Thanks a lot! :)

[Gillnetter]

Originally Posted by felliot

Hello!!! :)

I have enclosed it IN my application or
I have enclosed it TO my application?

Thanks a lot! :)

I have enclosed it in my application. It is inside the application.
I have attached it to my application. It is on or next to the application.

[riquecohen]

Also,--- I have enclosed it with my application,

[Tullia]

Originally Posted by Gillnetter

I have enclosed it in my application. It is inside the application.
I have attached it to my application. It is on or next to the application.

I would avoid using "enclosed it in" because, for me "enclosed" already contains the meaning "in". It seems tautological - it isn't, really, but it still jars to my ear somehow. I guess I'm fussy but it doesn't sound elegant to me.

Like riquecohen, I like "enclosed with" - I think because one doesn't really enclose something "in" an application; one puts the application and the other item in the envelope together. An application can't enclose another piece of paper. If you have stapled it to the application, it's attached not enclosed.

[Gillnetter]

Originally Posted by Tullia

I would avoid using "enclosed it in" because, for me "enclosed" already contains the meaning "in". It seems tautological - it isn't, really, but it still jars to my ear somehow. I guess I'm fussy but it doesn't sound elegant to me.

Like riquecohen, I like "enclosed with" - I think because one doesn't really enclose something "in" an application; one puts the application and the other item in the envelope together. An application can't enclose another piece of paper. If you have stapled it to the application, it's attached not enclosed.

If I prepare an application (a single piece of paper), fold the paper and insert my business card into the fold - didn't I put the business card in the application?

[Tullia]

Originally Posted by Gillnetter

If I prepare an application (a single piece of paper), fold the paper and insert my business card into the fold - didn't I put the business card in the application?

Hmmm. It's still not "enclosed" though, to my mind: surely to be "enclosed" there has to be more than one side (fold, in this case) to the enclosure?