Bookmark and Share

English Language Discussion Forums


Go Back   UsingEnglish.com ESL Forum > Learning English > English Idioms and Sayings > English Phrasal Verbs

Quick Links
Sites for Teachers


View Poll Results: Which would you use?
Not I 96 29.63%
Not me 149 45.99%
It depends [please explain...] 79 24.38%
Voters: 324. This poll is closed

Closed Thread
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 16-Oct-2003, 23:38
Editor, UsingEnglish.com
 
Join Date: Nov 2002
Country: UK
Posts: 29,023
Current Location: Tokyo
Native Language: English
Member Type: English Teacher
Tdol has disabled reputation
Default Not I

What part of speech is 'not' here?
Sponsored Links
  #2  
Old 17-Oct-2003, 15:09
Casiopea's Avatar
VIP Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Country: Canada
Posts: 12,989
Current Location: China
Native Language: English
Member Type: Other
Casiopea will become famous soon enoughCasiopea will become famous soon enough
Default Re: Not I

Quote:
Originally Posted by tdol
What part of speech is 'not' here?

It's an adverb.
Used elliptically.

Q: Who ate the cake?
A: Not me. (It was not me.) *popular

Q: Who ate the cake?
A: Not I. (It was not I.) *traditional grammar

According to traditional grammarians (Prescriptivist), linking verbs such as forms of 'to be' (is, are, was, were, etc.) link the subject with its complement. Complements refer back to the subject so they are considered 'nominative' (subject) in form. Which means, pronouns coming after the linking verb 'to be' should be nominative in form: I, she, he, we, they. For example,

Q: Who ate the cake?
A: Not I.

On the phone:

Pat: Hello, may I speak with Sam, please?
Sam: This is she.

But, keep in mind, those examples are based on what Prescriptivists would advise. As for Descriptivists, they'd point out that "me" is more popular these days than "I". The reason being, the pronoun comes after the verb which is a position reserved for objects, and hence speakers tend to choose "me" over "I" in that context.

Other 'not' example:

Q: Is she coming?
A: I hope not. (I hope she is not coming)

Q: Do you want it?
A: Certainly not! (I certainly do not want it.)

Cas :) That was fun! Thanx
  #3  
Old 17-Oct-2003, 15:39
RonBee's Avatar
Moderator
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Country: USA
Posts: 16,369
Current Location: North Carolina
Native Language: English
Member Type: Other
RonBee has a reputation beyond reputeRonBee has a reputation beyond reputeRonBee has a reputation beyond reputeRonBee has a reputation beyond reputeRonBee has a reputation beyond reputeRonBee has a reputation beyond reputeRonBee has a reputation beyond reputeRonBee has a reputation beyond reputeRonBee has a reputation beyond reputeRonBee has a reputation beyond reputeRonBee has a reputation beyond repute
Default

Good explanation!
  • "Who ate my porridge" said Baby Bear?
    "Not I" said Mama Bear.
    "Not I" said Papa Bear.

:wink:
  #4  
Old 17-Oct-2003, 21:33
Editor, UsingEnglish.com
 
Join Date: Nov 2002
Country: UK
Posts: 29,023
Current Location: Tokyo
Native Language: English
Member Type: English Teacher
Tdol has disabled reputation
Default Re: Not I

What do you think of the current usage of 'particle' for 'not'?
  #5  
Old 18-Oct-2003, 02:38
Casiopea's Avatar
VIP Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Country: Canada
Posts: 12,989
Current Location: China
Native Language: English
Member Type: Other
Casiopea will become famous soon enoughCasiopea will become famous soon enough
Default Re: Not I

Quote:
Originally Posted by tdol
What do you think of the current usage of 'particle' for 'not'?
Well, hmm, well, lemme see. The word 'not' in not at all and not quite and not John functions as an adverb. It negates the verb.

I slept until 6:00.
Not John. He did not sleep until 6:00.

Adverbs are major parts of speech, as are nouns, verbs, adjectives and prepositions.

Particles, on the other hand, are defined as minor parts of speech, especially short undeclinable ones, like the ones we see attached to phrasal verbs.

However, if you can show that not is a part of (a particle) of a phrasal verb, then I'd have to agree with using the term 'particle' in that particular context.

Do you have some examples?

Cas :)
  #6  
Old 18-Oct-2003, 13:43
Editor, UsingEnglish.com
 
Join Date: Nov 2002
Country: UK
Posts: 29,023
Current Location: Tokyo
Native Language: English
Member Type: English Teacher
Tdol has disabled reputation
Default

I'm not a fan of the term 'particle' at all. I think it's not particularly useful to have what is basically a dustbin category. I think of phrasal verbs consisting of verb & adverb combinations. Some use the term particle for 'not' and 'to' as the infinitive marker. Again, I'm not enamoured of this. I was interested to see what you thought.

Thanks
  #7  
Old 18-Oct-2003, 20:25
Editor, UsingEnglish.com
 
Join Date: Nov 2002
Country: UK
Posts: 29,023
Current Location: Tokyo
Native Language: English
Member Type: English Teacher
Tdol has disabled reputation
Default Re: Not I

Quote:
Originally Posted by "Casiopea

It's an adverb.
Used elliptically.

Q: Who ate the cake?
A: Not me. (It was not me.) *popular

Q: Who ate the cake?
A: Not I. (It was not I.) *traditional grammar

According to traditional grammarians (Prescriptivist), linking verbs such as forms of 'to be' (is, are, was, were, etc.) link the subject with its complement. Complements refer back to the subject so they are considered 'nominative' (subject) in form. Which means, pronouns coming after the linking verb 'to be' should be nominative in form: I, she, he, we, they. For example,

Q: Who ate the cake?
A: Not I.

On the phone:

Pat: Hello, may I speak with Sam, please?
Sam: This is she.

But, keep in mind, those examples are based on what Prescriptivists would advise. As for Descriptivists, they'd point out that "me" is more popular these days than "I". The reason being, the pronoun comes after the verb which is a position reserved for objects, and hence speakers tend to choose "me" over "I" in that context.

Other 'not' example:

Q: Is she coming?
A: I hope not. (I hope she is not coming)

Q: Do you want it?
A: Certainly not! (I certainly do not want it.)

Cas :) That was fun! Thanx
Which do you use? I would only use 'I' in very formal conversations.
  #8  
Old 18-Oct-2003, 21:07
RonBee's Avatar
Moderator
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Country: USA
Posts: 16,369
Current Location: North Carolina
Native Language: English
Member Type: Other
RonBee has a reputation beyond reputeRonBee has a reputation beyond reputeRonBee has a reputation beyond reputeRonBee has a reputation beyond reputeRonBee has a reputation beyond reputeRonBee has a reputation beyond reputeRonBee has a reputation beyond reputeRonBee has a reputation beyond reputeRonBee has a reputation beyond reputeRonBee has a reputation beyond reputeRonBee has a reputation beyond repute
Default

You would usually say not me, right?

:wink:
  #9  
Old 19-Oct-2003, 03:16
Casiopea's Avatar
VIP Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Country: Canada
Posts: 12,989
Current Location: China
Native Language: English
Member Type: Other
Casiopea will become famous soon enoughCasiopea will become famous soon enough
Default

Quote:
I think of phrasal verbs consisting of verb & adverb combinations.
You know, I've never thought of it that way. Thanks :)

Quote:
Some use the term particle for 'not' and 'to' as the infinitive marker.
Oo, I used to be a 'Some' once.

Some people are not sure how to classify 'not' and 'to', and hence their use of the catch-all term 'particle'.

Cas :)
  #10  
Old 19-Oct-2003, 03:25
Casiopea's Avatar
VIP Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Country: Canada
Posts: 12,989
Current Location: China
Native Language: English
Member Type: Other
Casiopea will become famous soon enoughCasiopea will become famous soon enough
Default Re: Not I

Quote:
Which do you use? I would only use 'I' in very formal conversations.
Me, too. So would I.

Or is it "I, too. So would me?" Hehe

I speak the Language of my generation--the "Me" generation. However, when communicating with speakers who(m) ascribe to traditional conventions, I tend to, but not always, use the nominative form, "I".

Cas :D
Closed Thread

Bookmarks

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On



All times are GMT. The time now is 17:26.


vBulletin, Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.3.2
Copyright © 2002 - 2010 UsingEnglish.com