During the day, I thought I would try my skill upon her.

Status
Not open for further replies.

diamondcutter

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2014
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
Chinese
Home Country
China
Current Location
China
“Oh, boys. Don't throw stones at the poor bird.” said an old grey-headed man.
“Sir,” said a little one, “she made such a loud noise that we can't bear her.”
“I am afraid the stone will rebound and hurt you as long as you live!”
“Rebound!” We don't understand you, sir.”
“Well, I will tell you a true story.”
“Fifty years ago, I liked throwing stones because I had no other boy to play with and I became very skillful. One day I went to work for an old couple who were very friendly to everybody even to the birds. And the birds seemed to love the old couple, too. For seven years a bird had come and built her nest in the same place. She and her mate had just returned on the day I went to work and the old couple welcomed them happily. During the day, I thought I would try my skill upon her. Suddenly the bird flew to a tree near me. I found a nice stone, and I threw it with my best skill. It hit the bird on the head and she dropped dead!

(Source: the English test paper, senior high school entrance exams, Henan province, China, 2021)

During the day, I thought I would try my skill upon her.

In the sentence above, I’d like to know whether it’s good to use “could” to replace “would”.
 
Yes, but it would change the meaning of the sentence. Also, the changed sentence probably wouldn't fit the story.
 
I thought I would try my skill upon her.
= I thought it was certain for me to try my skill upon her.

I thought I could try my skill upon her.
= I thought it was possible for me to try my skill upon her.

Am I right?
 
No, could is wrong.

Your approach to this isn't right. Focus on why would is the right verb here, not on trying to replace it with another.
 
I thought I would try my skill upon her.
= I thought it was certain for me to try my skill upon her.

Is my understanding above is correct?
 
I thought I would try my skill upon her.
= I thought it was certain for me to try my skill upon her.

I thought I could try my skill upon her.
= I thought it was possible for me to try my skill upon her.

Am I right?
No. He had already said he was good at throwing rocks. That means that when he threw a rock at something there was a good chance he would hit it.

Don't make things too complicated.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top