[Grammar] How Many Days Did Someone's Trip to ... ???

Status
Not open for further replies.

SongYuxiang

Junior Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2009
Member Type
Interested in Language
Native Language
Chinese
Home Country
China
Current Location
China
Dear Native English-speaking Teachers,

I read a question in a textbook, which sounds incorrect to me. Let me copy it down here for your confirmation.

"How many days did US President Barack Obama's scheduled trip to Shanghai and Beijing during his first official visit to China ? "

In my opinion, it should be :

"How many days would be US President Barack Obama's scheduled trip to Shanghai and Beijing during his first official visit to China ? "

or

"How many days did US President Barack Obama's scheduled trip to Shanghai and Beijing during his first official visit to China last? " (This one may sound less good, but not incorrect. Right)?

Thank you in advance.
 
Dear Native English-speaking Teachers,

I read a question in a textbook, which sounds incorrect to me. Let me copy it down here for your confirmation.

"How many days did US President Barack Obama's scheduled trip to Shanghai and Beijing during his first official visit to China ? "

In my opinion, it should be :

"How many days would be US President Barack Obama's scheduled trip to Shanghai and Beijing during his first official visit to China ? "

or

"How many days did US President Barack Obama's scheduled trip to Shanghai and Beijing during his first official visit to China last? " (This one may sound less good, but not incorrect. Right)?

Thank you in advance.
Not a teacher
Afain , President Obama took a trip to the china about one year ago If You are taking about that trip. I don't think it is correct to use "would be"
because he doesn't have any plans for a trip to the china anymore.(at least in 2010). So there is no EXPECTATION. However, if it has been written in 2009( before that trip), you could use "would be" .
 
Dear Native English-speaking Teachers,

I read a question in a textbook, which sounds incorrect to me. Let me copy it down here for your confirmation.

"How many days did US President Barack Obama's scheduled trip to Shanghai and Beijing during his first official visit to China ? "

In my opinion, it should be :

"How many days would be US President Barack Obama's scheduled trip to Shanghai and Beijing during his first official visit to China ? "

or

"How many days did US President Barack Obama's scheduled trip to Shanghai and Beijing during his first official visit to China last? " (This one may sound less good, but not incorrect. Right)?

Thank you in advance.
"How many days will US President Barack Obama's scheduled trip to Shanghai and Beijing be, during his first official visit to China ? " Asking about the future.

or

"How many days did US President Barack Obama's scheduled trip to Shanghai and Beijing last, during his first official visit to China ? " Asking about the past.
 
Thank you. Yes, it is written in a textbook mentioning the past event.
 
Thank you, Bhaisahab. I got it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top