I fixed/have fixed but I haven't fixed/didn't fix

EngLearner

Member
Joined
May 13, 2023
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Ukrainian
Home Country
Ukraine
Current Location
Ukraine
Bob is a mechanic. Chris provides him with customers and gets a commission for that. So Chris finds Peter, John and Bill, who are looking for a mechanic, and promises them to fix their cars. He gets their cars to Bob, and Bob starts working. In a couple of days, Chris thinks that Bob is still working, so he calls him and says: "How much longer will it take you?" To which Bob replies with one of the following sentences.

1. I'm finished. I've fixed Peter's car and John's, but I haven't fixed Bill's. I'm sorry, but I'm not competent enough to fix it.
2. I'm finished. I've fixed Peter's car and John's, but I didn't fix Bill's. I'm sorry, but I'm not competent enough to fix it.
3. I'm finished. I fixed Peter's car and John's, but I didn't fix Bill's. I'm sorry, but I'm not competent enough to fix it.


Which of the above versions would be appropriate in the context given?
 
Top