emackenzie
New member
- Joined
- Oct 23, 2014
- Member Type
- Student or Learner
- Native Language
- English
- Home Country
- United States
- Current Location
- United States
Hello everyone,
I understand that one of the primary purposes of the comma is to join two sentences whose content is very related; and, generally, a conjunction follows this comma. I have a sentence which curious about:
"Let one of them perish then, let another live, as their fortune wills; let him, as is his right and as his heart
pleases, work out whatever decrees he will on Danaans and Trojans."
This comes from Richmond Lattimore's translation of Homer's Liad; specifically, it is found on page 212 and is line 429.
If I understand correctly, "Let one of them perish" and "let another live" are actually two simple sentences joined by the comma. Thus, should there technically be the conjunction "and" just after the comma and just before the word "let;" nd is the conjunction left out for stylistic purposes?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Also, I have another question. If I understand correctly, "as their fortune wills" is a dependent clause, because it has the subject "fortune" and the verb "wills" (at least, I think that this is the verb). My question is, why do I sometimes see dependent clauses beginning with "as," like the given one, set off with a comma, and on some occasions it is not?
I understand that one of the primary purposes of the comma is to join two sentences whose content is very related; and, generally, a conjunction follows this comma. I have a sentence which curious about:
"Let one of them perish then, let another live, as their fortune wills; let him, as is his right and as his heart
pleases, work out whatever decrees he will on Danaans and Trojans."
This comes from Richmond Lattimore's translation of Homer's Liad; specifically, it is found on page 212 and is line 429.
If I understand correctly, "Let one of them perish" and "let another live" are actually two simple sentences joined by the comma. Thus, should there technically be the conjunction "and" just after the comma and just before the word "let;" nd is the conjunction left out for stylistic purposes?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Also, I have another question. If I understand correctly, "as their fortune wills" is a dependent clause, because it has the subject "fortune" and the verb "wills" (at least, I think that this is the verb). My question is, why do I sometimes see dependent clauses beginning with "as," like the given one, set off with a comma, and on some occasions it is not?