[Grammar] we have heard and understand/understood

Status
Not open for further replies.

Oceanlike

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 15, 2014
Member Type
Interested in Language
Native Language
Chinese
Home Country
Singapore
Current Location
Singapore
I’m unsure if I should use understand or understood in the sentence below. Due to ‘heard’, I’m inclined to use ‘understood’.

You don’t need to reiterate your point; we have heard and understand/understood what you’re saying.

Thank you for teaching me!
:-D
 
They're both acceptable.

We have heard and [we] understand.
We have heard and [we have] understood.
 
I don't understand why 'understand' is grammatically correct. Due to the presence of 'and', I thought it has to be 'understood'.

Kindly help me to understand why 'understand' is also correct.

Thank you! :-D
 
I think the auxiliary 'have' does not necessarily apply to the verb after 'and'.
 
She just said that they are acceptable. She didn't say why.
 
I think what she wrote suggests what I said in post#4.
 
Now I see. So you wrote why both can be acceptable.
 
I agree that both are acceptable, for the reasons already given, but I would also be inclined to use understood.
 
Arrgh...so embarrassing! Apparently, I didn't understand the explanation given :-(
 
Arrgh...so embarrassing! Apparently, I didn't understand the explanation given :-(
Both sentences say two things.
1a. "We have heard what you're saying" and b."We have understood what you're saying."
2a. "We have heard what you're saying" and b."We understand what you're saying."

If you still understand what you have understood, both sentences mean the same.
 
Crystal-clear explanation, Raymott! Awesome :-D
Many thanks!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top