swampwiz
New member
- Joined
- May 11, 2011
- Member Type
- English Teacher
- Native Language
- English
- Home Country
- United States
- Current Location
- Ukraine
I have been thinking about this. It seems that there is only one sub-mood (i.e., use) of the conditional mood - that of the apodosis for a hypothetical conditional statement.
"If I were rich, I would travel a lot more."
This hypothetical apodosis could be used in an implied hypothetical conditional statement as well(in fact, I just did it :-D)
What I implied was
"If the speaker intended to do so, this hypothetical spodosis could be used in ..."
It seems to me that all TRUE uses of the conditional mood are for this apodosis.
There is a common misconception - probably brought on by poor preparation of English teachers at their School of Education, so as to make grammar not so difficult for young learners - that anything that uses "would", "could", "should", "might" is conditional. While they can be used for the hypothetical apodosis, they could also be used for the hypothetical protasis sub-mood (i.e., sub-mood of the subjunctive.)
"If I could do better in school, I wouldn't be in danger of flunking out."
which implies, using the corresponding pseudo-modal (i.e., semi-modal)
"If I were able to do better in school, I wouldn't ..."
The use of "would" in a wish clause is the optative mood, that for whatever reason uses "would" - probably because "would" is incorrectly used in the subjunctive past sub-moods, if there is some personal involvement.
"I wish I would win a lot of money."
Also, the use of "would" for past habit is implied conditional
"Back in the day, I would drink a lot."
implies
"If I were in the past right now, I would be drinking a lot."
And the polite forms of questions are also implied conditional
"I would like to order a beer."
"Could you help me?"
implies
"If you would allow me to order, I would like to order a beer."
And "should" can even be used in the indicative mood:
"I should cook more often." (where is there any condition?)
As a side note, it should be noted that the use of "might", which has the connotation of a lower possibility than "may", is really the implied hypothetical apodosis:
"I might go swimming later."
implies
"If I feel like it, or if it is possible for me, etc., I might go ..."
The implication is that there is another hurdle of choice that must be gone through to get to the simple case of "may" probability, hence a lower probability than "may"
"If I were rich, I would travel a lot more."
This hypothetical apodosis could be used in an implied hypothetical conditional statement as well(in fact, I just did it :-D)
What I implied was
"If the speaker intended to do so, this hypothetical spodosis could be used in ..."
It seems to me that all TRUE uses of the conditional mood are for this apodosis.
There is a common misconception - probably brought on by poor preparation of English teachers at their School of Education, so as to make grammar not so difficult for young learners - that anything that uses "would", "could", "should", "might" is conditional. While they can be used for the hypothetical apodosis, they could also be used for the hypothetical protasis sub-mood (i.e., sub-mood of the subjunctive.)
"If I could do better in school, I wouldn't be in danger of flunking out."
which implies, using the corresponding pseudo-modal (i.e., semi-modal)
"If I were able to do better in school, I wouldn't ..."
The use of "would" in a wish clause is the optative mood, that for whatever reason uses "would" - probably because "would" is incorrectly used in the subjunctive past sub-moods, if there is some personal involvement.
"I wish I would win a lot of money."
Also, the use of "would" for past habit is implied conditional
"Back in the day, I would drink a lot."
implies
"If I were in the past right now, I would be drinking a lot."
And the polite forms of questions are also implied conditional
"I would like to order a beer."
"Could you help me?"
implies
"If you would allow me to order, I would like to order a beer."
And "should" can even be used in the indicative mood:
"I should cook more often." (where is there any condition?)
As a side note, it should be noted that the use of "might", which has the connotation of a lower possibility than "may", is really the implied hypothetical apodosis:
"I might go swimming later."
implies
"If I feel like it, or if it is possible for me, etc., I might go ..."
The implication is that there is another hurdle of choice that must be gone through to get to the simple case of "may" probability, hence a lower probability than "may"