|
#1
| |||
| |||
| 1. How would this sentence be parsed? 2. Is 'used to' a prepositional verb? 3. How does 'here', which is an adverb, modify 'being', which is a gerund (noun)? 4. What if 'your' was replaced with 'you', would the obect of 'to' be a fused participle of you and being? Thank you in advance, Donna |
|
#2
| ||||
| ||||
| Hello, Donna. Ex: I got used to your being here. 1. How would this sentence be parsed? I [subject] got [main verb] used to [adjectival] your being here [gerundival phrase] 2. Is 'used to' a prepositional verb? No. Got is the verb. Used to is adjectival. Cf. I am used to... 3. How does 'here', which is an adverb, modify 'being', which is a gerund (noun)? Gerunds are "verbal" nouns, meaning they have verbal qualities. So, they can indeed be modified by adverbs. The adverb here modifies the gerund being. We know it's an adverb because it answers the question Where? 4. What if 'your' was replaced with 'you', would the obect of 'to' be a fused participle of you and being? Sorry. I don't understand your question. You is the object of used to in this sentence: Ex: I got used to you being here. And, in turn, being here modifies you. |
|
#3
| |||
| |||
| Quote:
I will answer the second question. "Here" is an adverb. Obviously an adverb does not modify a noun. In fact it modifies "being", which is ocnsidered as a non-finite verb. The original sentence was: I got used to the fact [that you are here] By applying some transformational rules, the above sentence became: ....your being here. In fact, "being" is not a noun but a verb. As for your question about your/you, actually it is NOT possible to use "you". Why? Because the subject of a non-finite verb should be "your" and not You. "You", when coming as a subject, must take a finite verb. You are here vs. your being here. Examples: I do not agree that she stays here. => I do not agree her staying here. |
|
#4
| |||
| |||
| I got used to your being here. I am not sure but I feel that the above sentence can be best parsed as follows: I = Subject Got = Verb (It is here a linking verb) used to your being here = Compliment to your being late = Post modifier/preopositional phrase to = Head / preposition your being late = post modifier for the preposition 'to" your = subject , being = verb (non-finite) , here = adverbial NB. In parsing the above sentence, I followed Quirk et. al 1995. Comprehensive Grammar of English |
|
#5
| ||||
| ||||
| Hello, Mohammed Abu Risha. The problem with saying that being is not a noun, nominal your can't modify a verb, but it can modify other nominals (i.e., a gerund or a participle). In addition, what are your thought here? Spoken English accepts this phrase, you being here. In fact, it's pefectly grammatical. How does Quirk et al deal with this? Looking forward to hearing from you. |
|
#6
| |||
| |||
| Soup Thank you very much for your remark. Interesting. Is it correct in spoken English to say "you"? very interesting indeed. Randolph Quirck focuses only on written English grammar. As for "your being" point, according to Strcuture 1 and Strcuture 2 (Two books in syntax which heavily rely on Quirk et al), a clause can be divided into two types (according to verb form parameter): A finite clause (Example: You are here.) A non-finite clause (Example: your being here) The point I am raising now is that "your" DOES NOT modify "being". Rather, it is a subject! To explain the matter we may review the classification of a non-finite clause according to subject: Subject-explicit nonfinite clause Subject-implicit nonfinite clause. When you say: your being here---> This clause is nonfinite. It has an EXPLICIT subject (that is: your) and a nonfinite verb: being. When you say: being here --> This clause in non-finite. It has an IMPLICIT subject (The subject is there but hidden) and it has a non-finite verb "being" This issue is very complex and cannot in fact be encompassed in one or two posts. Regards Mar |
|
#7
| |||
| |||
| Quote:
Quote:
Sorry if this is overly simple, but what are we considering 'used to' for the purposes of it taking an object? A preposition? A verb? And, can't we consider 'your being here' the nominal phrase and object of 'used to'? And, I know you've pointed out that 'you being here' is grammatically correct, but isn't this is an anomaly? Usually a possessive is used with a gerund to clarify that it in fact is a gerund, because the subjective form would create confusion as to what the object is, you or your. Thanks again for your help, Donna |
|
#8
| |||
| |||
| Quote:
First let us agree that: to.....here is in fact a prepositional phrase as it has a head/preposition. After a preposition comes either: a noun a noun phrase or a noun clause Thereofore, "your being here" is indeed a nominal clause fucntioning as a complement for the preposition (to). Last edited by Mohammed Abu Risha; 22-Feb-2008 at 00:04. |
|
#9
| |||
| |||
| Hello Mohammed, I am not clear on what 'used to' is, among other issues. If you look at my post directly above this one - 2 up if we include yours - you can see where and how I am stuck. Thank you for your help in advance, Donna |
|
#10
| |||
| |||
| I got used to your being here. We were taught in the past that one way of analysing a sentence is through susbtitution: I got sad I got happy I got better Therefore, the element that comes after the copula "got" is an adjective. sad, happy and better are all adjectives. By the same token, "used to your being here" is an adjective if we want to follow the substitution rule. My feeling is that "used" is the head of the adjectival phrase "used to your being here". It should not be cosnidered as part of "used to" only. Once again we may re-parse the sentence as follows: I= This is a PRONOUN functioning as a SUBJECT got = This is a COMPULA functioning as a VERB used.....here = This is an ADJECTIVAL PHRASE functioning as a Subject COMPLEMENT The adjectival phrase has a phrase inside: to your being here= A Prepositional Phrase functionaing as POST MODIFIER (for "used") This prepositional phrase in turn has a clause inside: Your being here= Nominal Non-Finite Clause functioning as a Preposition COMPLEMENT your= Pronoun functioning as a Subject for the clause being = non-finite verb functioning as a verb for the clause here= Adverb functioning as Adverbial for the clause |
![]() |
| Bookmarks |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
| |
Similar Threads | ||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| sentence structure question | Unregistered | Ask a Teacher | 6 | 17-Jan-2008 09:53 |
| How to catch the main point of a complicated sentence? | sky753 | Ask a Teacher | 1 | 13-Sep-2006 14:07 |
| Attributive Clause - China Needs Your Help | ChinaDavid | Ask a Teacher | 5 | 09-Jan-2005 15:56 |
| Are there softwares to speak English sentence by sentence | Anonymous | Ask a Teacher | 2 | 18-Feb-2004 17:25 |
| grammar | jiang | Ask a Teacher | 8 | 17-Dec-2003 19:02 |