imchongjun
Member
- Joined
- Aug 21, 2007
- Member Type
- Interested in Language
- Native Language
- Japanese
- Home Country
- Japan
- Current Location
- Japan
Could you tell me if I understand correctly the sentence in bold in the following passage?
"Oh, that is an old door connected with another passage that leads by a dark and wearying staircase to the servants' corridor beneath! I am afraid you won't be able to open it, as it is rusty with age and disuse. The servants would as soon think of coming up here as they would of making an appointment with the Evil One; so it has not been opened for years." (The Haunted Chamber by "The Duchess")
I understand the sentence means "the servant would never dream of coming up here." My reasoning is as follows: the phrase "would as soon do X as Y" means "I would do X rather than Y," so the sentence means that the servants prefer coming up here to making an appointment with the devil. But "making an appointment with the devil" is a...how should I say...an extreme alternative. If the servants were forced to choose between "coming up here" and "making an appointment with the devil", they would choose "coming up here," but unless they are cornered into such an extreme situation, they would never think of "coming up here".
Am I correct? or mistaken? I appreciate your help very much.
"Oh, that is an old door connected with another passage that leads by a dark and wearying staircase to the servants' corridor beneath! I am afraid you won't be able to open it, as it is rusty with age and disuse. The servants would as soon think of coming up here as they would of making an appointment with the Evil One; so it has not been opened for years." (The Haunted Chamber by "The Duchess")
I understand the sentence means "the servant would never dream of coming up here." My reasoning is as follows: the phrase "would as soon do X as Y" means "I would do X rather than Y," so the sentence means that the servants prefer coming up here to making an appointment with the devil. But "making an appointment with the devil" is a...how should I say...an extreme alternative. If the servants were forced to choose between "coming up here" and "making an appointment with the devil", they would choose "coming up here," but unless they are cornered into such an extreme situation, they would never think of "coming up here".
Am I correct? or mistaken? I appreciate your help very much.
Last edited: