[Grammar] more than / rather than

Status
Not open for further replies.

whsans

Member
Joined
May 11, 2010
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
Korean
Home Country
South Korea
Current Location
South Korea
Thank you for reading my question :)
I got something curious I've never thought about
While reading a grammar book.

1. I love you more than him. (not to think of ambiguity)

That's a good sentence, and I don't see anything unnatural.
and 'I love more you than him' sounds strange.

but how about the following sentence?

2. I need money more than a car.

I kinda think 'I need more money than a car' is more natural...
There must be something different between two sentences...
but I can't see it.

but 'I need more money than a car' sounds like 'I need more money than before'

I'm confused so much...

which one of two sentences is correct? or both of them correct?

please help me out of this haunting curiosity...



and I found it out that 'rather than' should be stuck to each other
except for 'would rather A than B', so never mind.
 
Last edited:

Raymott

VIP Member
Joined
Jun 29, 2008
Member Type
Academic
Native Language
English
Home Country
Australia
Current Location
Australia
1. I love you more than him. (not to think of ambiguity)
It's unclear what you're saying. Do you mean you can see the ambiguity but that that is not your focus?

That's a good sentence, and I don't see anything unnatural.
and 'I love more you than him' sounds strange.
It is strange.

but how about the following sentence?

2. I need money more than a car.
This means, "I need money more than I need a car."
"My need for money is greater than my need for a car."


I [STRIKE]kinda[/STRIKE] think 'I need more money than a car' is more natural...
Well, it's not. That means "I need more money than a car needs."
And since a car doesn't need money at all, it is a bad sentence.

but 'I need more money than a car' sounds like 'I need more money than before'
Then forget "I need more money than a car". It's wrong.
"I need more money than before" = "I need more money than I did before"
"I need more money than my sister" = "I need more money than my sister does." (My sister needs less money than I do.)
R.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top