Curt Jugg
Junior Member
- Joined
- Jul 18, 2011
- Member Type
- Interested in Language
- Native Language
- English
- Home Country
- UK
- Current Location
- UK
In the sentence "He looked at the picture" is look being used as a copular verb?
I originally thought the answer must be no, but then I looked at it this way. As readers of A Comprehensive Grammar of the English Language will know Quirk et al. divide clauses into seven types ( section 2.16). The two types I'm interested in are SVO (subject+verb+object) and SVA (subject+verb+adverbial). They make it clear that "A" refers to an obligatory adverbial. In the same section they state that copular verbs are followed by a subject complement or an adverbial and occur in types SVC and SVA.
Now in section 8.32, "He looked at the picture" is analysed in two ways. In one, look at is regarded as a transitive verb with the picture as a direct object (clause type SVO); in the other, at the picture is regarded as an obligatory adjunct (clause type SVA - an adjunct is a type of adverbial of course). So if the verb in an SVA type is a copular verb and if one analysis of "He looked at the picture" is SVA, then look must be a copular verb in this case. If it isn't, will someone please tell me where I'm going wrong?
I originally thought the answer must be no, but then I looked at it this way. As readers of A Comprehensive Grammar of the English Language will know Quirk et al. divide clauses into seven types ( section 2.16). The two types I'm interested in are SVO (subject+verb+object) and SVA (subject+verb+adverbial). They make it clear that "A" refers to an obligatory adverbial. In the same section they state that copular verbs are followed by a subject complement or an adverbial and occur in types SVC and SVA.
Now in section 8.32, "He looked at the picture" is analysed in two ways. In one, look at is regarded as a transitive verb with the picture as a direct object (clause type SVO); in the other, at the picture is regarded as an obligatory adjunct (clause type SVA - an adjunct is a type of adverbial of course). So if the verb in an SVA type is a copular verb and if one analysis of "He looked at the picture" is SVA, then look must be a copular verb in this case. If it isn't, will someone please tell me where I'm going wrong?