Tack
Junior Member
- Joined
- Jun 11, 2010
- Member Type
- Student or Learner
- Native Language
- Japanese
- Home Country
- Japan
- Current Location
- Japan
I just bought a book "Common Errors in English" and found one sentence that I don't get.
"If you had phoned me last week, I would have told you"
This comes along with a picture that a bride imagining ex-boyfriend being told that she is married.
You can see this page at the link below. It's on Page 109.
www
scribd.com/doc/49025950/Common-Errors-in-English
But, to me, the following sentences are enough to explain the situation.
1. "If you phoned me last week, I told you"
2. "If you phoned me last week, I would told you"
3. "If you have phoned me, I would have told you"
Q1) Am I wrong?
The book explains that when imagining a different past, you need more than the past simple.
Q2) What two different situations are being imagined here? To me, it's just one situation like, what if he called me last week... or by last week.
I might not be understanding the whole situation well..
Q3) Would someone please explain to me what I am missing? What exactly is in her mind?? I don't understand it because I am a male?:-D
"If you had phoned me last week, I would have told you"
This comes along with a picture that a bride imagining ex-boyfriend being told that she is married.
You can see this page at the link below. It's on Page 109.
www
scribd.com/doc/49025950/Common-Errors-in-English
But, to me, the following sentences are enough to explain the situation.
1. "If you phoned me last week, I told you"
2. "If you phoned me last week, I would told you"
3. "If you have phoned me, I would have told you"
Q1) Am I wrong?
The book explains that when imagining a different past, you need more than the past simple.
Q2) What two different situations are being imagined here? To me, it's just one situation like, what if he called me last week... or by last week.
I might not be understanding the whole situation well..
Q3) Would someone please explain to me what I am missing? What exactly is in her mind?? I don't understand it because I am a male?:-D
Last edited: