An/The elephant has a long trunk???

[snoopy5376]

When we are saying a fact, for example:

Elephants have long trunks. (this is plural)

What about saying it in singular form? Should it be

1. An elephant has a long trunk.
2. The elephant has a long trunk.

Which is correct? I personally think that it should be 1. 2 sounds like that particular elephant has a long trunk but others don't have. Am i correct?

Thanks in advance.

 

[bhaisahab]

When we are saying a fact, for example:

Elephants have long trunks. (this is plural)

What about saying it in singular form? Should it be

1. An elephant has a long trunk.
2. The elephant has a long trunk.

Which is correct? I personally think that it should be 1. 2 sounds like that particular elephant has a long trunk but others don't have. Am i correct?

Thanks in advance.

Both and 2 are possible.

 

[snoopy5376]

Both and 2 are possible.

Oh, ok. Which is better or both are the same? Thanks ya. ;-)

 

[BobSmith]

[not a teacher]

An elephant has a long trunk. - always means a fact that applies to all elephants.
The elephant has a long trunk. - can be either a general fact, or a fact about a specific elephant, depending on context.

If it's a general fact, "the" references a hypothetical exemplar elephant. For example, in a film documentary, they might show you an elephant and say, "The elephant has a long trunk.", but it is understood that the fact applies to all elephants, and is (probably) not really referencing the one shown.

 

[snoopy5376]

If a picture as below is given,


which is more appropriate?:?:

 

[bhaisahab]

If a picture as below is given,
View attachment 1250

which is more appropriate?:?:

"The crocodile has a long tail" is appropriate, because we are talking about the crocodile in the picture.