brianbrian
Junior Member
- Joined
- Aug 1, 2014
- Member Type
- Student or Learner
- Native Language
- French
- Home Country
- France
- Current Location
- Canada
I would like to talk about the following questions.
(1a) Do any of the people in this room have a parrot at home?
(1b) Does any of the people in this room have a parrot at home?
Let me make up a few sentences for the next two questions.
A lion is an animal. Cherries are fruit. A pigeon is a bird. A baseball is smaller than a basketball.
(2a) Are any of these sentences interesting to you?
(2b) Is any of these sentences interesting to you?
I have heard from someone that (1a) and (2a) are correct, but not the other two. I thought that all of the examples above would be correct. The word, "any" could refer to one or more things. If "any" refers to one thing, then a singular verb is correct. If it refers to two or more things, then a plural verb is correct. Because we are not sure how many things "any" refers to, can I use either form of a verb?
Could someone please explain this? Thank you very much.
(1a) Do any of the people in this room have a parrot at home?
(1b) Does any of the people in this room have a parrot at home?
Let me make up a few sentences for the next two questions.
A lion is an animal. Cherries are fruit. A pigeon is a bird. A baseball is smaller than a basketball.
(2a) Are any of these sentences interesting to you?
(2b) Is any of these sentences interesting to you?
I have heard from someone that (1a) and (2a) are correct, but not the other two. I thought that all of the examples above would be correct. The word, "any" could refer to one or more things. If "any" refers to one thing, then a singular verb is correct. If it refers to two or more things, then a plural verb is correct. Because we are not sure how many things "any" refers to, can I use either form of a verb?
Could someone please explain this? Thank you very much.