Flavor of the Month: Why Smart People Fall for Fads

BUY FROM AMAZON.COM
Price: $21.95

Usually ships in 24 hours

By: Joel Best
(4 customer reviews)
Buy New: $21.95


Availability: Usually ships in 24 hours

EDITORIAL REVIEW

While fads such as hula hoops or streaking are usually dismissed as silly enthusiasms, trends in institutions such as education, business, medicine, science, and criminal justice are often taken seriously, even though their popularity and usefulness is sometimes short-lived. Institutional fads such as open classrooms, quality circles, and multiple personality disorder are constantly making the rounds, promising astonishing new developments--novel ways of teaching reading or arithmetic, better methods of managing businesses, or improved treatments for disease. Some of these trends prove to be lasting innovations, but others--after absorbing extraordinary amounts of time and money--are abandoned and forgotten, soon to be replaced by other new schemes. In this pithy, intriguing, and often humorous book, Joel Best--author of the acclaimed Damned Lies and Statistics--explores the range of institutional fads, analyzes the features of our culture that foster them, and identifies the major stages of the fad cycle--emerging, surging, and purging. Deconstructing the ways that this system plays into our notions of reinvention, progress, and perfectibility, Flavors of the Month examines the causes and consequences of fads and suggests ways of fad-proofing our institutions.

PRODUCT DETAILS

Publisher: University of California Press
Pub. Date: 10th April 2006
Catalog: Book
Media: Hardcover
Number Of Pages: 222
Ean: 9780520246263
Isbn: 0520246268

ABOUT THIS BOOK

USER REVIEWS

between three and four stars
~ Written on Aug 19, 2009. out of users found this review helpful.

as someone has already written "fairly obvious but well organized." I enjoyed it - a readable excursion into the world of fads, and for comparison, non-fads. (For example, wristwatches [although perhaps having rare much older examples] really surged into the US market after 1915, and some people thought they were "fads" like hula hoops but obvious watches were not.)

Fairly obvious observations, but well organized
~ Written on Feb 21, 2007. 4 out of 4 users found this review helpful.

Flavor of the Month is a 162 page essay/novel about institutional fads: why they exist, their different stages, and then a dissection on their pros and cons.

Although most of the observations are fairly obvious (institutional fads happen in cycles, etc) the information is well organized and presented. The major drawback to the book is that Best relies solely on "what if" stories. He creates fictional characters and places them in fictional situations to demonstrate how an institutional fad could begin, spread, and then fade away. The information would have been a lot more compelling if he were actually dealing with facts.

The book includes several copies of email forwards and other such jokes that you have probably seen repeatedly, and they get a little old, but add length to the book, which is their point I think.

I found Flavor of the Month easy to get through fairly quickly, but I'm not sure that I came away any more knowledgeable than before I opened the book. We all know that institutional fads happened, and I would rather have seen more examples of them happening in real life than a brief example of how they "could" effect a business.

lazyreaders.com book club selection for April 2006
~ Written on Jun 26, 2006. 5 out of 9 users found this review helpful.

So what if this book just came out, and I tend to always read books that are sent to me from publishers for free? While Joel Best can often bore with statistics (he wrote the wonderful "Damned Lies and Statistics"), his point of this book is intriguing: Americans often fall for scams. He is not talking about the guys that buy Ab Rollers sold on late night infomercials (which I own, pitifully). Best is talking about how smart people in business, medicine and education cling to the next 7-step approach or easy-to-use carb diet. Education, in my opinion, suffers from this disease more than any other profession, as the pendulum has swung most recently to drilling letter sounds and endlessly assessing students as a part of the government's "No Child Left Untested" program. If nothing else, this book will get you thinking. You can read an anecdote from my own teaching experiences on the April 2006 blog of my website, www.lazyreaders.com, which archives awesome adult, young adult and children's books that are under 250 pages.

What a disappointment.
~ Written on Apr 4, 2006. 19 out of 26 users found this review helpful.

I had read one of his previous books and thought it was okay. I was expecting this to have some entertaining examples of smart people falling for intellectual fads and some insights as to how that happens. Unfortunately, no such luck. All of the examples are ones that are widely known and there is really no insightful analysis. The book is quite short - all of the interesting content would barely fill a New Yorker article - and one gets the impression that this was just put together over a few weekends. I would have to say that the content is uniformly at the junior high school level. Save your money, no entertainment or enlightenment here.

SIMILAR ITEMS:

Search:
International
UK US
Browse Categories