[Grammar] ‘on the newspaper’ VS ‘with the newspaper’

Status
Not open for further replies.

northpath

Member
Joined
Nov 4, 2013
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Russian
Home Country
Russian Federation
Current Location
Russian Federation
I seem I’ve found these sentences in English dictionaries:
Julia works as a reporter on the local newspaper.
Tom is a news reporter with the local newspaper
.
Lena has a job with the local newspaper.
Are these prepositions Ok and interchangeable in this context?

And here's another: why when it comes to people in manual occupations, prepositions ‘at’ or ‘in’ are used. For instance:
Dave works at the automobile factory.
Tracy works in the local supermarket.

But when it comes to people of intellectual professions, preposition ‘with’ or ‘on’ are common. For instance:
Stephanie found work with an engineering firm.
Lena has a job with the local newspaper.
Can I say:
Stephanie found work at an engineering firm.
Julia works as a reporter at the local newspaper.
Tom is a news reporter in the local newspaper.
Lena has a job at the local newspaper.
 
Last edited:
I seem I’ve found these sentences in English dictionaries:
Julia works as a reporter on the local newspaper. :cross:
Tom is a news reporter with the local newspaper
.:tick:
Lena has a job with the local newspaper.:tick:
Are these prepositions Ok and interchangeable in this context? No, see above.

And here's another: why when it comes to people in manual occupations, prepositions ‘at’ or ‘in’ are used. For instance:
Dave works at the automobile factory.:tick:
Tracy works in the local supermarket.:tick:

But when it comes to people of intellectual professions, preposition ‘with’ or ‘on’ are common. For instance:
Stephanie found work with an engineering firm.:tick:
Lena has a job with the local newspaper.:tick:
Can I say:
Stephanie found work at an engineering firm.:tick:
Julia works as a reporter at the local newspaper.:tick:
Tom is a news reporter in the local newspaper.:cross:
Lena has a job at the local newspaper.:tick:

See above.
 
Ok, but if I say Stephanie found work with the local supermarket. or Dave has a job with the automobile factory. it would sound unnatural, right?
 
My first choice wouldn't be "with" but it's not wrong. I would probably use "with" if it were followed by a person's name or that person's job.

He found a job with the local carpenter.
I got a job with Bill Gates.

For your examples with "the local supermarket" and "the automobile factory", I would use "at".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ask a Teacher

If you have a question about the English language and would like to ask one of our many English teachers and language experts, please click the button below to let us know:

(Requires Registration)
Back
Top