[Grammar] is named instead of was named

Status
Not open for further replies.

englishhobby

Key Member
Joined
Jun 19, 2009
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
Russian
Home Country
Russian Federation
Current Location
Russian Federation
Can I say: "My niece is (not was) named after me and now she is my namesake"?
 
I prefer "was". But the "is" is not wrong.
 
"Was named" focuses on the time in the past when her parents decided on a name for her.
"Is named" focuses on the present and the fact that she has the same name as you.
 
Then can I say 'the email is sent' to mean that 'sent' is the present state of the email?

Not a teacher.
 
You have been on the forum long enough to know that you can't just automatically apply one construction or rule to another sentence.
 
"Is named" focuses on the present and the fact that she has the same name as you.
Then can I say 'the email is sent' to mean that 'sent' is the present state of the email?
At present she has the same name as the OP, but at present the email has reached the recipient or is being transmitted rather than 'is sent', so 'is sent' is wrong. May I understand it this way?

Not a teacher.
 
The e-mail is sent every day is OK (perhaps, if someone sends the same e-mail (spam?) every day). But you can't name someone (or give someone) a different name every day. The meaning of the verbs is different which causes different usage.

 
Then can I say 'the email is sent' to mean that 'sent' is the present state of the email?

In some circumstances, yes. If you're sitting at the keyboard, you could use it, but in most contexts, the present perfect would be more natural.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top