(American English) first time to V/Ving

[sitifan]

1. Is this your first time to stay here? (written by me)
2. Is this your first time staying here? (written by me)
3. Is this the first time that you have stayed here? (written by Michael Swan, modern standard British English)
https://www.usingenglish.com/forum/threads/84478-This-is-my-first-time-to-do-sth
Are #1 and #2 acceptable in American English?

 

[probus]

2 and 3 are perfectly correct and natural in AmE. Number 1 is unnatural.

 

[emsr2d2]

2 and 3 are perfectly correct and natural in AmE. Number 1 is unnatural.

That's the same in BrE.