bringing up vs upbringing

[ostap77]

I would say "Mike had a strict upbringing". Upringing is a noun and it's singular.

How about the following sentences?

1)"John pays a lot of attention to bringing up/raising his children"

OR

2)"John pays a lot of attention to the upbringing of his children"

Or

3)"John pays a lot of attention to upringing his children"

Guess the third one is kind of incorrect and unnatural. What do you think?

 

[bhaisahab]

I would say "Mike had a strict upbringing". Upringing is a noun and it's singular.

How about the following sentences?

1)"John pays a lot of attention to bringing up/raising his children"

OR

2)"John pays a lot of attention to the upbringing of his children"

Or

3)"John pays a lot of attention to upringing his children"

Guess the third one is kind of incorrect and unnatural. What do you think?

Yes, #3 is incorrect.

 

[riquecohen]

I would say "Mike had a strict upbringing". Upringing is a noun and it's singular.

How about the following sentences?

1)"John pays a lot of attention to bringing up/raising his children"

OR

2)"John pays a lot of attention to the upbringing of his children"

Or

3)"John pays a lot of attention to upringing his children"

Guess the third one is kind of incorrect and unnatural. What do you think?

You are correct about #3. You can´t use upbringing as a verb. Number 1 is correct. While #2 is also correct, I think it would sound better to say his children´s upbringing. (This is a matter of my personal preference.)

 

[ostap77]

You are correct about #3. You can´t use upbringing as a verb. Number 1 is correct. While #2 is also correct, I think it would sound better to say his children´s upbringing. (This is a matter of my personal preference.)

Cool. Thanks!

 

[Tullia]

There's also a subtle different between #1 and #2.

1)"John pays a lot of attention to bringing up his children"

2)"John pays a lot of attention to the upbringing of his children"

#1 implies John is doing the bringing up himself and is directly involved.

#2 is more ambiguous - the children could live with their mother, or be at a boarding school etc, but John knows what is going on, even if he's not directly involved.

It's a very very subtle difference though. Mostly they could be used interchangeably.

 

[ostap77]

There's also a subtle different between #1 and #2.

1)"John pays a lot of attention to bringing up his children"

2)"John pays a lot of attention to the upbringing of his children"

#1 implies John is doing the bringing up himself and is directly involved.

#2 is more ambiguous - the children could live with their mother, or be at a boarding school etc, but John knows what is going on, even if he's not directly involved.

It's a very very subtle difference though. Mostly they could be used interchangeably.

Ultimate explanation!