Capital Letter

Status
Not open for further replies.

panicmonger

Member
Joined
Apr 9, 2010
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Chinese
Home Country
China
Current Location
Australia
May I know why the capital letters(Prime Minister) have to be applied to the first sentence, whereas the second one doesn't have to?

1. The Prime Minister is attending the summit.
2. How is the French prime minister elected?

Thank you very much indeed.
 
The first refers to the current holder of the post - the second to the post itself.

Cf 'The Queen laid a wreath' and 'Which of us will be queen on the day of the carnival?'

Rover
 
Last edited:
May I know why the capital letters(Prime Minister) have to be applied to the first sentence, whereas the second one doesn't have to?

1. The Prime Minister is attending the summit.
2. How is the French prime minister elected?

Thank you very much indeed.


***** NOT A TEACHER

***** ONLY MY OPINION


Panicmonger,

I was fascinated by your question, for I, too, am interested in such

details.

It was interesting that the teacher told us that "prime minister" is

capitalized when referring to the current officerholder.

(1) I am now looking at my local newspaper (one of the top 5 American

papers) and its report on the recent G-20 meeting:

President Obama appeared to ....

British Prime Minister David Cameron warned of ....

Bank of China Chairman Xiao Gang called ....

... with South Korean President Lee Myung-bak.

THEN

The president began the day Thursday ....

My point:

If I remember correctly, when I was younger (much younger),

American newspapers always referred to the President.


For example:

The President is scheduled to visit our city today.

Somewhere along the line (I do not know when), most (all?)

newspapers changed the policy. Now "president" and other

titles are capitalized only when they proceed the person's

name. I am pretty sure that when this first started to become

used, I was astounded. Now I accept it as "normal." Our

newspapers often set the policy when it comes to punctuation.

For example, almost all American papers write: James' house. To

the best of my knowledge, The New York Times (our leading

paper) still insists on James's house.


Thank you

P.S. Yes, the word "the" in The New York Times is supposed to be

capitalized because the word "the" is actually in the paper's

name. But most American papers refer to it like this:

There was an interesting report this morning in the New York Times.

(They don't even italicize newspaper names anymore, either!!!)

The more you study English, the more you will learn how arbitrary

many "rules" are. That is, there is no particular reason. "Somebody"

decided X is correct, so everyone else said, "OK."
 
Thank you, TheParser.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ask a Teacher

If you have a question about the English language and would like to ask one of our many English teachers and language experts, please click the button below to let us know:

(Requires Registration)
Back
Top