Did you tell her?/Have you told her?

[Topstudent]

Father: You think you'll get some good presents for your birthday?
Daughter: I already know what Mom and Jake are giving me. A new bike.
Father: (to Jake) Did you tell her?/Have you told her?
Son/Jake: No, she saw it. It's out in the garage.

Are 'Did you tell her?' and 'Have you told her?' both correct and natural here? Thanks.

 

[emsr2d2]

"Did you tell her?" is the more natural of the two. "Have you told her?" is grammatically correct but it isn't what we would say in that context.

 

[Tarheel]

Say:

Are both correct and natural here?

Also, as has already been pointed out, because something is grammatically correct that doesn't make it natural speech. What's natural speech? It's what a person would be expected to say in the given context. (When a person says one thing one kind of response is expected. When a person says something else a different kind of response is expected.)