(Having been) written by a famous writer, the book sells well.

[sitifan]

1. Being written by a famous writer, the book sells well.
2. Having been written by a famous writer, the book sells well.
3. Written by a famous writer, the book sells well.
AI says #3 is much better than #1 or #2. Do native speakers agree with that?

 

[jutfrank]

Much better than #2? By what criteria did you ask AI to judge that?

Also, why have you posted this in the linguistics section?

 

[sitifan]

Also, why have you posted this in the linguistics section?

I thougt it belonged to syntax.

 

[sitifan]

Much better than #2? By what criteria did you ask AI to judge that?

Which of the sentences below is better to native speakers?
1. Being written by a famous writer, the book sells well.
2. Having been written by a famous writer, the book sells well.
3. Written by a famous writer, the book sells well.
-------------------------------------------------------
Sentence 3 is by far the most natural and standard to a native speaker: "Written by a famous writer, the book sells well."