[Grammar] He said it is/was going to rain.

[wotcha]

1. He said it is going to rain.

2. He said it was going to rain.


Why is 1 correct? I think 2 is grammatical because he "said" not "says".



Thank you.

 

[Barb_D]

I would backshift to "was" in that case, but if he just said it a moment ago and I simply couldn't hear him, then "is" is okay.

Him: It's going to rain
Me: Sorry, I couldn't hear that.
Him: It's going to rain.
Me, to you: Could you hear him?
You: Yes. He said it's going to rain.
Me: Thank you. You don't have to shout.

 

[billmcd]

1. He said, "It is going to rain". (If reported in print); If reported in speech, as in your post #1, ("said", a minute ago, yesterday, last week etc.; "is going to", a prediction)

2. He said it was going to rain. A. "Look, it's sunny" B. "Yeah, I know, the weatherman said it was going to rain today."


Why is 1 correct? I think 2 is grammatical because he "said" not "says".



Thank you.

b.