[Grammar] I wished I had been rich. I wished I were rich.

Status
Not open for further replies.

wotcha

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 29, 2010
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
Korean
Home Country
South Korea
Current Location
South Korea
1. I wished I had been rich.

2. I was sorry I was not rich.

3. I was sorry I had not been rich.



4. I wished I were rich.

5. I was sorry I was not rich.



I've read about numerous examples of 'I wish subjunctive' and

come across several different explanations of if sentence 1 and 4.


My question here is

First, which sentence between 2 and 3 is same as sentence 1 in meaning?

Second. do you native speakers really say like sentence 4?

If then, can we change sentence 4 to sentence 5 ?


Thank you so much teachers.
 
Last edited:
First, which sentence between 2 and 3 is same as sentence 1 in meaning?

Second. do you native speakers really say like sentence 4?

If then, can we change sentence 4 to sentence 5 ?


Thank you so much teachers.
Leaving aside any discussion of whether "I wished I was ..." means the same as "I was sorry I was not ...":
More context is needed to tell whether 1 means something closer to 2 or 3.
2. suggests that the being sorry and the not being rich occurred at the same time in the past. 3. suggests that the not being rich occurred at some time before the being sorry about it, and that there was some relevant intervening fact (as one would expect with the past perfect). 1. is ambiguous about this, but the context would help.

4. No. I would say "I wished I was rich".
Yes you can change it with 5. if you think nothing would be lost in meaning, as per my first line.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top