Like [that/those]

Status
Not open for further replies.

Sped Tiger

Junior Member
Joined
Mar 1, 2023
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
German
Home Country
Germany
Current Location
Germany
Would you tell me which is correct in my context? Maybe both are? Maybe there's a difference?
1. The nouns Germany, Italy, Kenny, Kenedy and others like [that/those] only require an -s for the plural
 
only require an -s for the plural
Most words only require an s for the plural. I think you mean "only require an s without changing the y to ie".

Would you tell me which is correct in my context?

You need "them", not "that" or "those".

I'd suggest you say "and some others ending with y" or "and most proper nouns ending with y". Saying "others like them" would mean all nouns ending with y follow that rule, which isn't true.

Note that it's Kennedy and not Kenedy. (Also, I'm not sure you'll ever need to pluralise Germany or Italy.)
 
Most words only require an s for the plural. I think you mean "only require an s without changing the y to ie".



You need "them", not "that" or "those".

I'd suggest you say "and some others ending with y" or "and most proper nouns ending with y". Saying "others like them" would mean all nouns ending with y follow that rule, which isn't true.

Note that it's Kennedy and not Kenedy. (Also, I'm not sure you'll ever need to pluralise Germany or Italy.)
Italy, incidentally, is an exception, namely: Italy - Italies.
 
Both the -ys and -ies form are used for both countries. Ngram.
 
I'm not sure you'll ever need to pluralise Germany
We commonly used the plural form when we had a German Democratic Republic and a Federal Republic of Germany.
 
This is apparently a question of taste, but I think the b) versions look silly:

a) two Germanys
b) two Germanies

a) two Italys
b) two Italies
 
1. The nouns ... Italy ... only require an -s for the plural

Italy, incidentally, is an exception, namely: Italy - Italies.
If you think it is, why did you include it in your list in your first post?

I can't recall coming across the plural form of "Italy"; there's only one after all and the plural would only be used in a figurative sense, but I'd expect "Italys".
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ask a Teacher

If you have a question about the English language and would like to ask one of our many English teachers and language experts, please click the button below to let us know:

(Requires Registration)
Back
Top