so is he / as is he

[masterding]

"so is/was does etc " and "as is/was/does etc" both carry the meaning of " what has just been said is also true about someone or something else" , So what's the difference between the two phrases?
Thanks.

 

[BobK]

The meaning's essentially the same - more a question of register: 'as + <verb> + <subject>' is more formal; the 'as' version also implies an 'and':

You want it, as do I = You want it, and so do I. The implied 'and' might be replaced by a sentence break: 'You want it. So do I.'

It's not only more formal, but used in rhetoric: Obama might say 'They want justice, as do we all', whereas his predecessor might have said 'They want a fair crack of the whip, and - heck - so do we'. ;-)

b

 

[5jj]

Obama might say 'They want justice, as do we all', whereas his predecessor might have said 'They want a fair crack of the whip, and - heck - so do we'.

I think he's more likely to have said, "...heck - we'll whip 'em".

 

[~Mav~]

Please, forgive me for being off-topic, but having read the last two posts, I couldn't resist sharing this picture with you. :-D I hope ya'll don't mind it, and the respected moderators won't open up a can of whoop ass on me. ;-) (I wonder if anyone uses this phrase. :-? )

:mrgreen:

 

[5jj]

I din't know the expression, but was interested to learn it.
Urban Dictionary: a can of whoopass

 

[BobK]

OK, I started it with an ill-chosen example , but let's get back on topic. ;-) Any other views on the 'so/as' question?

b

 

[masterding]

It seems that you guys are making fun of Mr. George W. Bush , however I don't quite understand the humor, maybe I should start a new thread about that whipass thing.:-D
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_W._Bush