tricky questions

Status
Not open for further replies.
J

john_nash

Guest
I hope someone could give me a hand on this enigma.
Since the present participle clauses are the reduced form of relative clauses, for example:

My sister who is looking left and right is trying to cross the road.
My sister looking left and right is trying to cross the road.

That's why they cannot be substituded for non-continuning actions, for example:
My sister who saw the car accident is terrified.
My sister seeing the car accident is terrified. (not correct)

I wonder If I could use "to-infinitive clause" to replace the relative clause, just like:
My sister to see the car accident is terrified.

This question can be helpful to everyone, pls help me.
pls,,,...
 

Raymott

VIP Member
Joined
Jun 29, 2008
Member Type
Academic
Native Language
English
Home Country
Australia
Current Location
Australia
I hope someone could give me a hand on this enigma.
Since the present participle clauses are the reduced form of relative clauses, for example:

My sister, who is looking left and right, is trying to cross the road.
My sister, looking left and right, is trying to cross the road.

That's why they cannot be substituded for non-continuning actions, for example:
My sister, who saw the car accident, is terrified.
My sister, seeing the car accident, is terrified. (not correct)

Unless you are trying to define which sister you mean, you need to use commas. I think you mean these clauses to be non-defining.

I wonder If I could use "to-infinitive clause" to replace the relative clause, just like:
My sister to see the car accident is terrified.
No, this doesn't make sense.

This question can be helpful to everyone, pls help me.
pls,,,...
R.
 

mayita1usa

Member
Joined
May 11, 2010
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
American English
Home Country
United States
Current Location
United States
I wonder If I could use "to-infinitive clause" to replace the relative clause, just like:
My sister to see the car accident is terrified.

It works if you invert it, but it makes more sense in the past tense:
My sister was terrified to see the car accident.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top