Which shirt would you like..?

[Banglardon]

Which of these sentences are grammatical?


1- I have shirts of many colours in my shop. Which shirt would you like, a blue one, a red one or a green one.

2- I have shirts of many colours in my shop. Which shirt would you like, a blue, a red or a green?

3- I have shirts of many colours in my shop. Which shirt would you like, a blue shirt, a red shirt or a green shirt.

4- Which ones are your favourite fruit, apples or mangoes?

 

[5jj]

The main problem with #1-3 is that no shop assistant would utter them. All shops sell different coloured shirts; There is no need to state the obvious.

They may have a limited range of shirts in a particular style or size, in which case this is possible: We have red, blue and green in this style/size. What colour do you prefer?

 

[jutfrank]

I think Banglardon is trying to practise using which.

Banglardon, please tell us clearly what you are trying to learn here.

 

[Banglardon]

I think Banglardon is trying to practise using which.

Banglardon, please tell us clearly what you are trying to learn here.

I want to understand the difference between which and which one.

Here are two examples:

A- Which one is your favourite, apples or mangoes.

B- Which is your favourite, apples or mangoes.

 

[emsr2d2]

I want to understand the difference between which and which one.

Here are two examples:

A- Which one is your favourite, apples or mangoes.

B- Which is your favourite, apples or mangoes.

You have made a very basic punctuation error in both A and B. Please use the Edit Post facility to fix the errors and then we can deal with your query.