Wuthering Heights: repetition of a personal pronoun

Status
Not open for further replies.

Walt Whitman

Member
Joined
Jan 4, 2012
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
Italian
Home Country
Italy
Current Location
Italy
When Lockwood felt better, Zillah, the housekeeper, handed him a candle, took him upstairs to his bedroom and gave him some strange advice: she told him to be quiet, because she was putting him in a room that her master never let anyone use.

Does it sound unnatural to repeat the pronoun “him” so many times?
Is there a better way to write the sentence?

Thank you
WW
 
Does it sound unnatural to repeat the pronoun “him” so many times?
Is there a better way to write the sentence?
No.
There are other ways, not necessarily better, for example:

When Lockwood felt better, Zillah, the housekeeper, handed him a candle, led the way upstairs to his bedroom and gave some strange advice: she said he should be quiet, because she was putting him in a room that her master never let anyone use.
 
Is it quite wrong or just bad English?
 
I don't think that line is from the original book. It sounds like a line from a simplified version.
 
@Walt Whitman Two things. One, do you really think it's bad writing? Two, you haven't given anybody any likes.
 
I don't think that line is from the original book. It sounds like a line from a simplified version.

Ah, yes, you're right. This is not from the original Wuthering Heights.
 
I was perplexed. Then, I saw 5jj change “Yes” to “No”, and I felt relieved.

Barque is right. I’ve been working for some time on a simplified version of the original text. It’s for personal use only. I love Emily Brontë’s only novel. The passage was just my attempt at simplifying the beginning of chapter 3.
 
I was perplexed. Then, I saw 5jj change “Yes” to “No”, and I felt relieved.
I thought I'd changed it before anybody read my original post. Sorry. I'd misread the question.
 
I read your original post too and was wondering what to make of your next line that said "There are other ways, not necessarily better ..." I didn't realise you'd changed it till I saw Walt Whitman's #10.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top