Yes, I (have/did) and she forgave me.

[Marika33]

Which of those work as a reply (and which do not if any)?

-Have you apologized to Sarah for forgetting her birthday?
1.-Yes, I have and she forgave me.
2.-Yes, I did and she forgave me.
3.-Yes, and she forgave me.

 

[Piscean]

Which of those work as a reply (and which do not if any)?

-Have you apologized to Sarah for forgetting her birthday?
1.-Yes, I have and she forgave me.
2.-Yes, I did and she forgave me.
3.-Yes, and she forgave me.

1. OK.
2. Some will say this, but don't give that response in tests.
3. OK.


You could also say ' ... and she has forgiven me' in all of them.

 

[PeterCW]

I would only use 1 or 3 in response to that question. If I was asked "did you apologise..." then I would use 2.

 

[Marika33]

Thank you all!

I asked this question because I had thought that if I used the perfect tense "Yes, I have", I couldn't use the past simple after it "and she forgave me". Like it should be the past simple after the past simple, and should not be the past simple after the present perfect.

1. -Yes, I have and she forgave me.
2. -Yes, I did and she forgave me.