Nightmare85
Senior Member
- Joined
- Jul 17, 2009
- Member Type
- Interested in Language
- Native Language
- German
- Home Country
- Germany
- Current Location
- Germany
Hey guys,
A long time ago we discussed the topic "was, were - would be".
We decided that we can replace "would be" with "were", however, not always.
Furthermore we said "was" cannot be used instead of "would be".
I disagree.
For many months I've been hearing was plenty of times where "would be" would have been possible, too.
Unfortunately, I would need to check all videos but I don't have time now.
Instead I will show it based on lyrics (Yes, I know lyrics aren't a good example, but it should be enough for this.)
Vanilla Ice - Ice Ice Baby
If there was a problem yo I'll solve it
Check out the hook while my DJ revolves it
I believe that we could write a "would be" instead of the "was".
However, we learned that "was" is wrong, it has to be either "were" or "would be".
Now my opinion why "was" can be true, as well.
(I need to re-write the sentence with the hope that it would be still grammatically correct.)
If there was a problem I solved it.
(If there would be a problem I would solve it.)
In my opinion the sense of this sentence cannot be misunderstood.
You can't think it's past, because it would make no sense.
And now directly compared:
When there was a problem I solved it. -> past (maybe when you tell something about your groundskeeper job.)
Even here you can't really misunderstand its sense.
Okay, in case someone has not gotten the main question:
Can't we use was instead of would be if were would be possible, too :?:
Cheers!
A long time ago we discussed the topic "was, were - would be".
We decided that we can replace "would be" with "were", however, not always.
Furthermore we said "was" cannot be used instead of "would be".
I disagree.
For many months I've been hearing was plenty of times where "would be" would have been possible, too.
Unfortunately, I would need to check all videos but I don't have time now.
Instead I will show it based on lyrics (Yes, I know lyrics aren't a good example, but it should be enough for this.)
Vanilla Ice - Ice Ice Baby
If there was a problem yo I'll solve it
Check out the hook while my DJ revolves it
I believe that we could write a "would be" instead of the "was".
However, we learned that "was" is wrong, it has to be either "were" or "would be".
Now my opinion why "was" can be true, as well.
(I need to re-write the sentence with the hope that it would be still grammatically correct.)
If there was a problem I solved it.
(If there would be a problem I would solve it.)
In my opinion the sense of this sentence cannot be misunderstood.
You can't think it's past, because it would make no sense.
And now directly compared:
When there was a problem I solved it. -> past (maybe when you tell something about your groundskeeper job.)
Even here you can't really misunderstand its sense.
Okay, in case someone has not gotten the main question:
Can't we use was instead of would be if were would be possible, too :?:
Cheers!