Eric Davis
Junior Member
- Joined
- Feb 23, 2010
- Member Type
- Student or Learner
In the following sentence, is "working on the project" a participle phrase?
I am busy working on the project.
I am busy working on the project.
I don't know the grammarians' answer to your question. In my opinion, it can be either a participle or a gerund phrase. Maybe this could be a clue (it's a clue to me): does 'busy' go with nouns? I think it does not. So maybe it doesn't go with gerunds (which are noun-like) either? But:In the following sentence, is "working on the project" a participle phrase?
I am busy working on the project.
It's a present continuous sentence.I don't know the grammarians' answer to your question. In my opinion, it can be either a participle or a gerund phrase. Maybe this could be a clue (it's a clue to me): does 'busy' go with nouns? I think it does not. So maybe it doesn't go with gerunds (which are noun-like) either? But:
1) it is not a satisfying reasoning,
2) it is grammar, not maths so any reasoning can be wrong.
***NOT A TEACHER***In the following sentence, is "working on the project" a participle phrase?
I am busy working on the project.
I don't think it's a present continuous sentence. I mean it perhaps can be be thought of this way, but I certainly don't find it present contiuous. I am not native, but I'm quite sure there are natives who would agree.It's a present continuous sentence.
"Busy" does "go with nouns", "a busy city", "a busy road" etc. where "busy" is an adjective describing "road" and "city" respectively.
With "busy", it's not continuous tense. And without adding a preposition, it's not a gerund. Also, the sentence doesn't need a preposition.In the following sentence, is "working on the project" a participle phrase?
I think it is. "busy" and "working on the project" both modify "I".
I am busy working on the project.
Your argument is what makes me even more uncertain. I was leaning towards the participle option, but now, I see that it is (as I expected) more complicated.***NOT A TEACHER***
Good morning, Mr. Davis.
(1)There are many ways to analize your sentence.
(2) Every analysis deserves our respect.
(3) This is how I analyze it.
(a) I may be wrong. But a fellow has to settle on something. Otherwise, he will go stark raving mad.
(4) According to everything that I have been able to find in books and on the Web, "working on the project" is a gerund phrase.
(5) It is the object of an unstated preposition.
(6) It seems that ages ago, the people in England used "a-" as a preposition. A gerund then followed. Here are two examples from a scholarly paper I stumbled across on the Web:
(a) The bees are busy a-hoarding honey. Today: The bees are busy (in) hoarding honey.
(b)Nannie has been busy a-ironing this evening. Today: Nannie has been busy (at) ironing this evening.
(7) If ( a big "if") you accept this theory, then your sentence = I am busy (deleted a- preposition) working on the project.
(8) All you can do is to study all the answers in this thread, read some books, and search the Web. Then you will have to make up your own mind -- as did I.
Thanks so much for making me exercise my brain this morning.
In the following sentence, is "working on the project" a participle phrase?
I am busy working on the project.