Conatus
Member
- Joined
- Oct 6, 2013
- Member Type
- Student or Learner
- Native Language
- Portuguese
- Home Country
- Brazil
- Current Location
- Brazil
Hello teachers and colleagues:
According to the following definitions from Cambridge Dictionay Online, a "bag" is necessarily made of soft material; if the material is hard (rectangular), then it would be a "suitcase":
a) definitiion for "bag", in this case: "a softcontainer made out of paper or thinplastic, or a strongercontainer made of leather, plastic, or other material, usually with a handle, in which you carrypersonal things or clothes or other things that you need for travelling
b) definitiion for "suitcase":"a large, rectangular case with a handle for carryingclothes and possessions while travelling"
Once a hotel clerk called my large suitacase on wheels a bag and since then I've been seen frequently people calling a suitcase a bag.
I searched for both words in the forum and I found this answer by Casiopea to a question about the differences between this two words, among others:
"suitcase <singular>
=> a case for a traveler's belongings
handbag <singular>
=> a bag that holds your money, credit cards, keys, and so on
bag
=> a synonym for handbag, suitcase; also, sport's bag, school bag, lunch bag, grocery bag, shopping bag, and so on"
My questions:
1- Does people only call a small or medium size carry-on suitcase (synonym for handbag on the above answer) a bag? Or a large suitcase as well?
2 - Is "bag" as a synonym for suitcase according to the English semantics? or is this use of the word with this meaning considered slang ore something like that?
3 - Is "bag" commonly used a synonym to "suitcase" in both British and American English?
According to the following definitions from Cambridge Dictionay Online, a "bag" is necessarily made of soft material; if the material is hard (rectangular), then it would be a "suitcase":
a) definitiion for "bag", in this case: "a softcontainer made out of paper or thinplastic, or a strongercontainer made of leather, plastic, or other material, usually with a handle, in which you carrypersonal things or clothes or other things that you need for travelling
b) definitiion for "suitcase":"a large, rectangular case with a handle for carryingclothes and possessions while travelling"
Once a hotel clerk called my large suitacase on wheels a bag and since then I've been seen frequently people calling a suitcase a bag.
I searched for both words in the forum and I found this answer by Casiopea to a question about the differences between this two words, among others:
"suitcase <singular>
=> a case for a traveler's belongings
handbag <singular>
=> a bag that holds your money, credit cards, keys, and so on
bag
=> a synonym for handbag, suitcase; also, sport's bag, school bag, lunch bag, grocery bag, shopping bag, and so on"
My questions:
1- Does people only call a small or medium size carry-on suitcase (synonym for handbag on the above answer) a bag? Or a large suitcase as well?
2 - Is "bag" as a synonym for suitcase according to the English semantics? or is this use of the word with this meaning considered slang ore something like that?
3 - Is "bag" commonly used a synonym to "suitcase" in both British and American English?
Last edited: