navi tasan
Key Member
- Joined
- Nov 19, 2002
- Member Type
- Academic
- Native Language
- Persian
- Home Country
- Iran
- Current Location
- United States
Are these sentences correct and logical?
1) This is the story of three men who were all in love with a woman. That woman was Sally Atkinson.
2) We have five ladies on our show tonight who come from different backgrounds but who have one thing in common. They all love a TV show. And that show is ours.
The first sentence in #1 would normally lead one to think that they are in love with three different women. But could it be used if it is the same women?
The problem in #2 is basically the same, from a logical point of view.
1) This is the story of three men who were all in love with a woman. That woman was Sally Atkinson.
2) We have five ladies on our show tonight who come from different backgrounds but who have one thing in common. They all love a TV show. And that show is ours.
The first sentence in #1 would normally lead one to think that they are in love with three different women. But could it be used if it is the same women?
The problem in #2 is basically the same, from a logical point of view.