[Grammar] Cloze test

[hooshdar3]

"Chidren who cannot yet tug may talk on the ear ------a sign of pain."
1)for 2)like 3)from 4)as

Which choice is correct and why?

 

[Raymott]

"Chidren who cannot yet tug may tug on the ear ------a sign of pain."
1)for 2)like 3)from 4)as

Which choice is correct and why?

Hmm, 86 posts and you still don't know the drill?
Here it is: What do you think the answer is and why?

 

[hooshdar3]

Hmm, 86 posts and you still don't know the drill?
Here it is: What do you think the answer is and why?

I myself answered 4 since it didn't feel bad, and the answer key gives 4 too and doesn't explain that.

I wonder why it should be the only correct answer?since 1) seems fitting too, and maybe even 2)

 

[Raymott]

I myself answered 4 since it didn't feel bad, and the answer key gives 4 too and doesn't explain that.
Yes, I would have chosen 4 - though it's not strictly correct.

I wonder why it should be the only correct answer?since 1) seems fitting too, and maybe even 2)

The problem with 4. (and 1) is that, even if a baby tugging an ear is a sign that the baby is in pain, the baby does not do it as a sign of pain. (The baby does not think, "I'll tug my ear so that they'll know I'm in pain.")
"Children who cannot yet tug may tug on the ear as a sign of pain."
No. They may tug on their ear in an attempt to free themselves of pain, or as a simple reflex, and it may alert the parent that the baby has ear pain, but the child is not doing it as a sign (I believe).

 

[hooshdar3]

sorry, I corrected my first post:

"Chidren who cannot yet talk may talk on the ear ------a sign of pain."
1)for 2)like 3)from 4)as

Which choice is correct and why?

 

[Barb_D]

It's still as, though everything Ray says makes sense to me as to why it's a poorly expressed idea.

 

[hooshdar3]

What does "tug on" mean?

 

[riquecohen]

What does "tug on" mean?

It means to pull on something.
Look here. Definitions of tug - OneLook Dictionary Search
OneLook Dictionary is an excellent site for word definitions. It will link you to many dictionaries that define your word.

 

[hooshdar3]

It means to pull on something.
Look here. Definitions of tug - OneLook Dictionary Search
OneLook Dictionary is an excellent site for word definitions. It will link you to many dictionaries that define your word.

How can you pull on something?
Doesn't pull mean over?

 

[bhaisahab]

How can you pull on something?
Doesn't pull mean over?

No, you can pull on/off/out/out of, etcetera.

 

[hooshdar3]

No, you can pull on/off/out/out of, etcetera.

And all of them mean the same?

 

[bhaisahab]

And all of them mean the same?

No, I didn't say that. Look up phrasal verbs on google.