"Did you know I’m a big bike riding fan" or "Did you know I was a big bike riding fan"?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Mori

Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2008
Location
Isfahan
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
Persian
Home Country
Iran
Current Location
Iran
Consider the following conversation:

John: I live in London.
Dave: Really? I didn't know you lived (NOT live) in London.

That's how I've always asked my students to use the second verb tense according to the previous one, i.e. sequence of tenses. I was surprised when I saw the following today:

M: What are you doing this afternoon?
F: Nothing special. Why?
M: You want to go bike riding?
F: Did you know I’m a big bike riding fan?
M: Actually, no, I didn’t.
F: It’s true. I ride my bike every weekend—rain or shine.
M: That’s great!

Source: Top Notch 1

Shouldn't it be did you know I was a big bike riding fan?
 
Last edited:
What's Top Notch 1?
 
John: I live in London.
Dave: Really? I didn't know you lived (NOT live) in London.
While we wait for you to provide the rest of the source information, please note that your example dialogue is very unnatural. No native speaker would say what Dave said. We'd say "Really? I didn't know that".
 
This native speaker would always choose the past tense over the present in both examples. I think this phenomenon is known as backshifting, but of course I defer to those who know more grammar than I (that is, practically everybody😀).
 
@Mori An imaginary conversation. (They are not talking face to face )

John: I live in London.
Dave: I didn't know that.
John: In fact, I grew up here. Come for a visit sometime, and I'll show you around. We'll do all the touristy things.
Dave: That's a great idea!


Some of us do what jutfrank calls backshifting. Others--not so much.
 
Last edited:
When in doubt, backshift – it will always be right.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top