"Have you cleaned it?"

[Rachel Adams]

Hello.

This sentence is from Murphy's Essential Grammar in Use.
"I asked you to clean the bathroom. Have you cleaned it?"
Would a native speaker say: "Did you clean it?"

 

[GoesStation]

The speaker will use the present perfect if they're mainly wondering whether you cleaned the bathroom very recently. They'll use the past simple if they're thinking more about whether the job is complete than when it was done.

 

[emsr2d2]

Also, having used "clean" in the opening sentence, we're unlikely to use it again in the question.

I asked you to clean the bathroom. Have you done it?
I asked you to clean the bathroom. Did you do it?
I asked you to clean the bathroom. Have you?
I asked you to clean the bathroom. Did you?

 

[Phaedrus]

This sentence is from Murphy's Essential Grammar in Use.
"I asked you to clean the bathroom. Have you cleaned it?"
Would a native speaker say: "Did you clean it?"

"Cleaned it" and "clean it" are awkward in the respective second sentences of each example. Normally, a native speaker would use ellipsis there:

I asked you to clean the bathroom. Have you?
I asked you to clean the bathroom. Did you?

P.S. I see that ems and I made the same point simultaneously.

 

[Rachel Adams]

The speaker will use the present perfect if they're mainly wondering whether you cleaned the bathroom very recently. They'll use the past simple if they're thinking more about whether the job is complete than when it was done.

Both are possible because it's not the situation where we are identifying the person, thing, or circumstances responsible for a present situation. Right? As it's written in Swan. ( We are thinking about the past cause, not the present result). Compare: "Look what Jack's given me!" (Thinking about the gift).
"Who gave you that?" (Thinking about the past action of giving)
"Somebody has spilt coffee on the carpet."
"Who spilt all that coffee on the carpet?"
"Why are you crying?" "Granny hit me." (Not "has hit me")
"I am glad you were born".
"How did you get that bruise?"
"That's a nice picture. Did you paint it yourself?"