I gave him a box, inside the box was a gift.

Status
Not open for further replies.

theol

Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2020
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Korean
Home Country
Japan
Current Location
Japan
I gave him a box, inside the box was a gift.

Is a comma a good way to connect these two sentence? If not, how can I make changes of it?
 
I gave him a box, inside the box was a gift.

Is a comma a good way to connect these two sentence? If not, how can I make changes of to it?
No, a comma will not work because it creates a comma splice. Either use a period and start a new sentence, or use a semi-colon. A third option is to use a coordinating conjunction with the comma. The final option would be a subordinating conjunction, although you have rather limited possible choices with these two particular clauses.
 
Last edited:
@theol You can keep the comma if you do this:

I gave him a box, and inside the box was a gift.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
You can avoid repetition of box by forming a relative clause:

I gave him a box, inside which was a gift.
I gave him a box, which had a gift inside.


Another option is to use with:

I gave him a box with a gift inside.
 
I can't help envisioning a mother saying to her daughter 'Pandora, whatever you do, don't open that box your Uncle Zeus gave you.

I said 'DON'T OPEN THAT BO ... AWW CRA ...
 
(y)I can't help envisioning a mother saying to her daughter 'Pandora, whatever you do, don't open that box your Uncle Zeus gave you.

I said 'DON'T OPEN THAT BO ... AWW CRA ...

Sounds like a Neil Gaiman short story in the making.(y)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top