# living/live

Status
Not open for further replies.

#### mmasny

##### Key Member
What are you more likely to say: a live lobster or a living lobster?
"We should respect all the live creatures." or "We should respect all the living creatures."?

#### euncu

##### Senior Member
I guess, the word "creatures" implies "the living"

We should respect all the living or,
We should respect the living

#### mmasny

##### Key Member
I guess, the word "creatures" implies "the living"

We should respect all the living or,
We should respect the living
Did you mean that "living" implies "creatures"? I guess so because you omit "creatures", not "living" and one can omit what is implied, not what implies (I can be wrong - I have just finished my mathematical logic course and my brain is a mess now ). I can agree with that, but I don't think we are supposed to speak always in the shortest, non-pleonasmic way. By the way it's a bit off-topic

#### euncu

##### Senior Member
Maybe it depends on the one who speaks, but I don't regard a stone as a creature, but I do for a tree, a cat,etc. So,to me, it doesn't make a difference to call the creatures as the living.

#### rlfwood

##### Junior Member
What are you more likely to say: a live lobster or a living lobster?
"We should respect all the live creatures." or "We should respect all the living creatures."?

live lobster, "We should respect all living creatures."

#### mmasny

##### Key Member
live lobster, "We should respect all living creatures."
Ok, thank you very much. Would you, please, explain what the difference is? I mean, I chose these the examples so that I get an impression through them and I did. But I still couldn't verbalize the difference and am still not sure if I know it already.

#### rlfwood

##### Junior Member
I'm not sure I could verbalize a difference, either. It's a matter of usage, rather than strict definition.

This is perhaps an example of why it is generally more fruitful to spend your time reading (in the language that you're learning) rather than in trying to memorize rules. Reading will help you attune your ear to the conventional usages of the language.

#### Raymott

##### VIP Member
I guess, the word "creatures" implies "the living"

We should respect all the living or,
We should respect the living
No, a creature may be dead, and thus not living.
Dying doesn't change whether an entity was initially created.

#### euncu

##### Senior Member
No, a creature may be dead, and thus not living.
Dying doesn't change whether an entity was initially created.

Agree. There were already no implication that those who live will live forever

Status
Not open for further replies.

Replies
7
Views
680
Replies
13
Views
14K
Replies
9
Views
3K
Replies
11
Views
1K
[General] Live or living
Replies
10
Views
2K