[Grammar] No sooner

Status
Not open for further replies.

faisaljan

Member
Joined
Apr 6, 2014
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Urdu
Home Country
Pakistan
Current Location
Pakistan
1. No sooner we left the shop it began to rain.
OR
2. No sooner we left the shop when it began to rain.
 
No sooner had we left the shop than it began to rain.
Hardly had we left the shop when it began to rain.
Not a teacher.
 
No sooner had we left the shop than it began to rain. :up:
Hardly had we left the shop when it began to rain. :down:
Not a teacher.

At least in my dialect, "Hardly had we" is not used.
We had hardly left when...
We had barely left when...

You have the "no sooner" part exactly right.
 
Last edited:
At least in my dialect, "Hardly has we" is not used.
Hello.:-D
I'd like to quote from Practical English Usage (Third Edition) by Michael Swan.
On page 281, he says:

[...] Inversion is also used after restrictive words like hardly (in BrE), seldom, rarely, little and never, and after only + time expression. This is formal or literary.
Hardly had I arrived when trouble started. (BrE) [...]

So, it's correct in BrE. It's not used in AmE.:-D
 
Is it also possible?
Scarcely had we left the shop when it began to rain.
 
Glad I added the caveat about it not be used in my dialect.
 
Is it also possible?
Scarcely had we left the shop when it began to rain.

I am not a teacher.

'Hardly', 'barely' and 'scarcely' can all be used more or less interchangeably in this sort of phrase. It can sound a bit dated, though.

"No sooner had we left..." can also be expressed by "No sooner did we leave..."
 
At least in my dialect, "Hardly had we" is not used.
Do you mean New York dialect?

Also, I found something amiss: hardly had I thanked for your post when the OP's "thanked" disappeared.
 
I consider myself a New Yorker actually. I spent ages 1-22 living in that state. However my parents are from California and the South, which influenced my speech greatly. I've lived only in the northeastern part of the country. But yes, I did mean "American" in general.
 
I believed you to be in eastern PA. Didn't know you were from NY. No offense meant.
 
I currently live in PA but I will never consider myself a Pennsylvanian. It's not "home." But certainly nothing offensive either way!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ask a Teacher

If you have a question about the English language and would like to ask one of our many English teachers and language experts, please click the button below to let us know:

(Requires Registration)
Back
Top