monaka
New member
- Joined
- Jun 19, 2007
- Member Type
- Student or Learner
- Native Language
- Japanese
- Home Country
- Japan
- Current Location
- Japan
Hello, I want to ask about the usage of "Singular vs Plural" issue on the following sentence, which was once corrected by an English native speaker.
Before the correction ):
Jack is keeping a record of dinner pictures. He marked some evaluation of its satisfaction as a meal.
After the correction ):
Jack is keeping a record of dinner pictures. He marked some evaluation of THEIR satisfaction as a meal.
The point I want to be sure is
#1 whether I don't neet to change the latter part of 2nd sentence like this:
He marked some evaluation of THEIR satisfaction as MEALS.
I was writing the 2 sentences from a view of focusing on each meal. Therefore I used "its" + "as a meal".
However, the corrector told me that since I was talking about pictures so "its" should be "their".
Ok, I understand this one, but then, is it Ok to leave the "as a meal" part as singular?
Isn't it similar issue like saying:
The guys who hit their wives should be imprisoned. (sorry, for the example.)
A guy who hit his wife should be imprisoned.
This is really tough to explain in English but is there anyone who can see my point?
Any suggestion of saying like, "Look up at ***** chapter in ******* grammar book for this or that will help me a lot too!!
Thank you.
Before the correction ):
Jack is keeping a record of dinner pictures. He marked some evaluation of its satisfaction as a meal.
After the correction ):
Jack is keeping a record of dinner pictures. He marked some evaluation of THEIR satisfaction as a meal.
The point I want to be sure is
#1 whether I don't neet to change the latter part of 2nd sentence like this:
He marked some evaluation of THEIR satisfaction as MEALS.
I was writing the 2 sentences from a view of focusing on each meal. Therefore I used "its" + "as a meal".
However, the corrector told me that since I was talking about pictures so "its" should be "their".
Ok, I understand this one, but then, is it Ok to leave the "as a meal" part as singular?
Isn't it similar issue like saying:
The guys who hit their wives should be imprisoned. (sorry, for the example.)
A guy who hit his wife should be imprisoned.
This is really tough to explain in English but is there anyone who can see my point?
Any suggestion of saying like, "Look up at ***** chapter in ******* grammar book for this or that will help me a lot too!!
Thank you.