taking

Status
Not open for further replies.

wowenglish1

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 4, 2006
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Korean
Home Country
South Korea
Current Location
South Korea
Once a hare was roaming near a lake in a forest. Suddenly he saw a tortoise and mocked at him saying – “Hurry up, you slow coach! Don’t you find life very dull taking so long to cover a few yards? I could have run to the other side of the lake by now.”

1. I would like to know the subject of "taking"
2. I wonder if "taking" is gerund or participle.
 
Last edited:
Once a hare was roaming near a lake in a forest. Suddenly he saw a tortoise and mocked at him saying – “Hurry up, you slow coach! Don’t you find life very dull taking so long to cover a few yards? I could have run to the other side of the lake by now.”

1. I would like to know the subject of "taking"
2. I wonder if "taking" is gerund or participle.

As far as I know:
1- "taking so long to cover a few yard" is a participle phrase.
2- This participle phrase functions as a modifier.
3- What does it modify? I am not sure, But I might say that it modifies the subject of the main sentence:"you".
 
I am not a teacher, and the terminology of English grammar is not standardized.

"Taking" is a participle heading a participial phrase used as an adjective (taking so long to cover a few yards). Such a participle is said to have an object (long) instead of a subject. The phrase modifies a pronoun that is not there, "you" (Don’t you find life very dull [you] taking so long to cover a few yards?) We normally do not bother to repeat the pronoun just so the participle has a playmate.
 
Last edited:
Here's another opinion:

you / do find life / dull

(when?) taking so long to cover a few yards

"find life" is an idiom and acts as a verb in this sentence.

the "taking" phrase acts as an adverb telling when one finds things dull.
 
Here's another opinion:

you / do find life / dull

(when?) taking so long to cover a few yards

"find life" is an idiom and acts as a verb in this sentence.

the "taking" phrase acts as an adverb telling when one finds things dull.

"an adverb telling when one finds things dull"
I interprete your opinion this way: it's a participle phrase which modifies the clause before it("Don't you find life dull?").

I wrote that it modifies the subject of the previous clause, but I was not sure. Your suggestion sounds better to me.
 
you / do find life / dull
[...]
"find life" is an idiom and acts as a verb in this sentence.
'Find life' is hardly an idiom. "Find' is the verb, not find life'. Here are some other examples of this verb in use:

I find life exciting
Many learners find this forum useful.
Don't you find such attitudes frustrating?
George found things very difficult after his dismissal.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ask a Teacher

If you have a question about the English language and would like to ask one of our many English teachers and language experts, please click the button below to let us know:

(Requires Registration)
Back
Top