[Grammar] "We had ourselves had" ?

Status
Not open for further replies.

DiamondBlueMoon

New member
Joined
Jul 2, 2013
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Vietnamese
Home Country
Vietnam
Current Location
Vietnam
Recently i came across an essay in one of my student books, which is kinda interesting. However, i'm confused about the structure of a sentence in the last paragraph:
"Then my father reminded me of the narrow escape that we had ourselves had."

I'm wondering if that kind of structure is past perfect or something else, and please explain more if it's different from PP. Thank you.
 
Recently i came across an essay in one of my student books, which is [STRIKE]kinda [/STRIKE]interesting. However, i'm confused about the structure of a sentence in the last paragraph:
"Then my father reminded me of the narrow escape that we had ourselves had."

I'm wondering if that kind of structure is past perfect or something else, and please explain more if it's different from PP. Thank you.
Yes, it's past perfect, "had had". The bolded part means the same as "we had had ourselves".

PS: "Kinda" isn't a word. If you need an adverb to modify 'interesting', there are plenty of real words available. We prefer real words on this site because it's less confusing for students.
 
Recently I came across an essay in one of my student books, which is [STRIKE]kinda [/STRIKE] [please do not use informal expressions, these might mislead learners into thinking they are acceptable standard English]interesting. However, I'm confused about the structure of a sentence in the last paragraph:
"Then my father reminded me of the narrow escape that we had ourselves had."

I'm wondering if that kind of structure is past perfect or something else, and please explain more if it's different from Past Perfect [use full nomenclature whenever there is a chance for ambiguity: PP could also be understood as Present Perfect, or Past Participle, or Present participle, or what not]. Thank you.

IMO, "...of the narrow escape we had had ourselves" or "...of the narrow escape we had ourselves" are better options, depending on the speaker's intention. And yes, the first case is Past Perfect.

Also, please remember to always capitalize the first person singular pronoun, "I".

Edit: I was late this time! ;-)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ask a Teacher

If you have a question about the English language and would like to ask one of our many English teachers and language experts, please click the button below to let us know:

(Requires Registration)
Back
Top