[Grammar] which one is correct

Status
Not open for further replies.

Babai

Junior Member
Joined
Nov 1, 2011
Member Type
Interested in Language
Native Language
Bengali; Bangla
Home Country
India
Current Location
India
a. I belive him to be honest. b. I belive him honest.
 
You could use Option A, although where I'm from we tend to say "I believe he is an honest man" (there are many other options too). Option B is incorrect.
 
'I believe him (to be) honest?' Would have been a much more useful title for this thread.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Note the correct spelling of "believe".
 
1/ According to Practical English Usage | Oxford University Press, some verbs of thinking and felling such as believe, consider , feel ... can be followed by object + infinitive ( usually to be) in a formal style. However, after believe, consider , find and think , it is often possible to drop to be before adjectives and sometimes ( especially with consider) before noun.
Examples: I considered him (to be) an excellent choice.
We found her ( to be) delightful.
They believe her (to be) reliable.
2/ According to Oxford advanced Dictionary: [believe + N + ADJ] Three sailors are missing, believed drowned.
( extracted from Oxford Advanced Dic.)
3/ According to Cambridge Advanced Learner's Dictionary: [ believe + object + adjective ] All the crew are missing, believed dead.
( extracted from Cambridge Advanced Learner's Dictionary)
 
1/ According to Practical English Usage | Oxford University Press, some verbs of thinking and felling such as believe, consider , feel ... can be followed by object + infinitive ( usually to be) in a formal style. However, after believe, consider , find and think , it is often possible to drop to be before adjectives and sometimes ( especially with consider) before noun.
Examples: I considered him (to be) an excellent choice.
We found her ( to be) delightful.
They believe her (to be) reliable.
2/ According to Oxford advanced Dictionary: [believe + N + ADJ] Three sailors are missing, believed drowned.
( extracted from Oxford Advanced Dic.)
3/ According to Cambridge Advanced Learner's Dictionary: [ believe + object + adjective ] All the crew are missing, believed dead.
( extracted from Cambridge Advanced Learner's Dictionary)

"...it is often possible to drop to be before adjectives and sometimes ( especially with consider) before a noun."
I have marked the key words in red. It doesn't work with "I believe him honest."
 
1/ According to Practical English Usage | Oxford University Press, some verbs of thinking and felling such as believe, consider , feel ... can be followed by object + infinitive ( usually to be) in a formal style. However, after believe, consider , find and think , it is often possible to drop to be before adjectives and sometimes ( especially with consider) before noun.
Examples: I considered him (to be) an excellent choice.
We found her ( to be) delightful.
They believe her (to be) reliable.
My third edition does not give the "They believe her (to be) reliable" example; It gives only " They believed her to be reliable" and "They believed that she was reliable". It mentions the dropping of 'to be' after only 'consider'. Which edition are you quoting?
2/ According to Oxford advanced Dictionary: [believe + N + ADJ] Three sailors are missing, believed drowned.
( extracted from Oxford Advanced Dic.)
3/ According to Cambridge Advanced Learner's Dictionary: [ believe + object + adjective ] All the crew are missing, believed dead.
( extracted from Cambridge Advanced Learner's Dictionary)
Fine, but your examples #2 and #3 are rather different from the sentence we started with.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ask a Teacher

If you have a question about the English language and would like to ask one of our many English teachers and language experts, please click the button below to let us know:

(Requires Registration)
Back
Top