Why are there so many rules in English grammar? Is every rule considered necessary?

english_extreme

New member
Joined
Jun 15, 2023
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Indonesian
Home Country
Indonesia
Current Location
Indonesia
Except for basic rules that I know are necessary, there are some excessive rules that have no benefits other than to complicate things for the user because a whole sentence is already self-explanatory.
For example:
I go to school.
He go to school.
He go to school yesterday.
The above 3 sentences are self-explanatory without the proper English verb 'went' and 'goes'.

One mouse, two mouse, three mouse. Instead of one mouse, two mice, three mice.

Even a native speaker also admits that there is another language that is easier than English to use.
 
Last edited:

SoothingDave

VIP Member
Joined
Apr 17, 2009
Member Type
Interested in Language
Native Language
American English
Home Country
United States
Current Location
United States
Nobody designed or invented the language. There have always been simplified pidgins that facilitate communication and commerce.

There is, however, a vast difference in the ideas that can be expressed with a pidgin versus the actual language.
 
Last edited:

5jj

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 14, 2010
Member Type
English Teacher
Native Language
British English
Home Country
Czech Republic
Current Location
Czech Republic
As so often happens when people make claims about the implicity of some language, the speaker in #1 exaggerates the simplicity of Indonesian. He suggests that Indonesian das only one form for verbs - much simpler than eat/ate or go/went. He fails to mention such forms as these:

  • ajar = to teach
  • ajari = to teach (imperative, locative)
  • ajarilah = to teach (jussive, locative)
  • ajarkan = to teach (imperative, causative/applicative)
  • ajarkanlah = to teach (jussive, causative/applicative)
  • ajarlah = to teach (jussive, active)
  • ajaran = teachings
  • belajar = to learn (intransitive, active)
  • diajar = to be taught (intransitive, active)
  • diajari = to be taught (transitive, locative)
  • diajarkan = to be taught (transitive, causative/applicative)
  • dipelajari = to be studied (locative)
  • dipelajarkan = to be studied (causative/applicative)
  • mempelajari = to study (locative)
  • mempelajarkan = to study (causative/applicative)
  • mengajar = to teach (intransitive, active)
  • mengajarkan = to teach (transitive, casuative/applicative)
  • mengajari = to teach (transitive, locative)
  • pelajar = student
  • pelajari = to study (imperative, locative)
  • pelajarilah = to study (jussive, locative)
  • pelajarkan = to study (imperative, causative/applicative)
  • pelajarkanlah = to study (jussive, causative/applicative)
  • pengajar = teacher, someone who teaches
  • pelajaran = subject, education
  • pelajari = to study (jussive, locative)
  • pelajarkan = to study (jussive, causative/applicative)
  • pengajaran = lesson
  • pembelajaran = learning
  • terajar = to be taught (accidentally)
  • terajari = to be taught (accidentally, locative)
  • terajarkan = to be taught (accidentally, causative/applicative)
  • terpelajar = well-educated, literally "been taught"
  • terpelajari = been taught (locative)
  • terpelajarkan = been taught (causative/applicative)
  • berpelajaran = is educated, literally "has education"
 
Top