You two are liable to be on the news, yourselves!

Status
Not open for further replies.

wowenglish1

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 4, 2006
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Korean
Home Country
South Korea
Current Location
South Korea
What does "C" mean by " the next sentence"?
You two are liable to be on the news, yourselves!



A: By the way, last night on the news, they showed a beached whale being rolled back into the ocean.

B: What makes you think of that?
A: Beats me.
C: You two are liable to be on the news, yourselves!

view_submsg3.cgi
 
The man lying down assumes (probably correctly) that the other two have been reminded about the story about the beached whale by the fact that he is rather fat and resembles a whale himself. I think his final sentence is a threat - he has understood their "joke" about his size and is threatening to hurt/kill them (or something) as a result. If that happens, they will probably be featured on the news as well.

I should point out that his threat is (I hope) meant as a joke! ;-)
 
The man lying down assumes (probably correctly) that the other two have been reminded about the story about the beached whale by the fact that he is rather fat and resembles a whale himself. I think his final sentence is a threat - he has understood their "joke" about his size and is threatening to hurt/kill them (or something) as a result. If that happens, they will probably be featured on the news as well.

I should point out that his threat is (I hope) meant as a joke! ;-)

While literally it could be taken as a threat, in AmE at least, the term liable is frequently used synonymously with "possible" i.e. as a possibility. (A) "Look at those dark clouds over there." (B) "Yeah, it's liable to rain any minute." (A) "That guy has been double parked for about an hour." (B) "I know. He's liable to get a ticket."
 
It's still a threat, as far as I can see.
 
I agree: Man buries cheeky children up to their necks in the sand. Film at 11! (Not that he really would, of course.)
 
It's still a threat, as far as I can see.

As I posted previously, I understand "liable" can be used as a threat, particularly in the context represented by the cartoon, but use of 'liable' simply as a possibility is also a possibility (no pun intended). Given one of the examples I used, i.e. (A) "That guy has been double parked for an hour."(B) "I know. He's liable to get a ticket." "B" doesn't know the "guy" (driver), so I don't see it as a threat or even a caution. He is simply stating his opinion to "A" about the possibility that the driver might get a ticket.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ask a Teacher

If you have a question about the English language and would like to ask one of our many English teachers and language experts, please click the button below to let us know:

(Requires Registration)
Back
Top