Poll: The magician sawed his assistant...
- Votes: 415
- Comments: 2
- Added: December 2004
- Polls: 1,170
- Votes: 689,399
- Comments: 4,855
"In half" implies that there are two pieces, making "halves" redundant.
Saying "in halves" would work if you were splitting two different objects at one time. i.e. They split the pizzas each into halves.