people got running water

Status
Not open for further replies.

bart-leby

Member
Joined
May 2, 2014
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Czech
Home Country
Czech Republic
Current Location
Czech Republic
I have just read an article about the Islamic State and have problems with this sentence:



For so long, progress and the decline of faith – what enlightened types prefer to call “superstition” – were thought to be symbiotic if not synonymous. As the world advanced, as more of its people got running water, TV and smartphones, surely the old, primitive beliefs would fade.



I am not able to comprehand the part "more of its people got running water". Literal meaning does not make any sense to me in the context. Is it a sort of idiomatic structure? Thank you.
 
I am not a teacher.

It is the literal meaning. Running water, TV and smartphones are given as examples of progress.
 
Hi Roman.

I have contacted Jonathan via email
here, but he hasn't replied. Do you think that he might mean having access to safe water, is fit to drink/having water facilities, please?
 
I am not a teacher.

Yes, that is what's normally meant by 'running water'. Clean water supplied by a state-run or private service which implies a certain level of (industrial) progress. It's considered preferable to having to walk five miles to the nearest river or waterhole.
 
"Running water" usually refers to indoor plumbing.
 
"Running water" usually refers to indoor plumbing.

Yep, that's a sign of progress, like the others the writer listed. We say "running" in this sense of "flowing," as through pipes to a faucet. It does not mean "fleeing water" or "people running with water" or "water used by people on the run."
 
Nevertheless, like the OP, I can't see the relation between running water and religion ('primitive beliefs'). No one says, "I've lost my faith since we got the plumbing on." In that sense, it's a metonym for "civilisation", or something similar, not just a literal phrase.
 
Are TV and smartphones also "metonyms"? I think the meaning is clearly literal.
 
No, in the context, it's easy to see how TVs and smartphones can contribute to the spread of rationality (though I would have mentioned the internet). If you can explain how running water washes away 'primitive beliefs', I'll concede that it's not a metonym.
 
It is simply another sign of progress -- literal progress.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ask a Teacher

If you have a question about the English language and would like to ask one of our many English teachers and language experts, please click the button below to let us know:

(Requires Registration)
Back
Top